Spacetime diagrams, the interval and the twin paradox
A spacetime diagram plots events with x across and ct up. Light moves at 45∘
Lesson 2 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
A map of events
A road map has two directions, east and north. A spacetime diagram (also called a Minkowski diagram) also has two: position x across and time ct up. Each point is an event. A body traces a line, its worldline.
A body at rest has a vertical worldline: its x does not change.
A body moving at v has a worldline that leans, with Δx/Δ(ct)=β.
Light has Δx=cΔt. Its worldline is at 45∘. Nothing can lean further than light.
The axes of a moving frame
How does a frame S' moving at β look on the diagram of S? Its ct′ axis is the worldline of its origin, x′=0, which is the line x=βct. Its x′ axis is the set of events with t′=0, which is the line ct=βx. Both axes lean towards the light line by the same angle θ, with
tanθ=β
To read an event's coordinates in S', draw lines from it parallel to the two tilted axes. Lines of equal t′ are tilted. That is the relativity of simultaneity in a picture. The scale along the tilted axes is also stretched, so we read numbers from the Lorentz transformation, not with a ruler.
The interval
Different observers disagree about Δx and Δt between two events. But they all agree on one combination, the interval
s2=(cΔt)2−Δx2
(with Δy2+Δz2 also taken away in three dimensions). Check it with the worked example of the last lesson, the origin and the event (1500m,1200m). In S, s2=12002m2−15002m2=−810000m2. In S', s2=3752m2−9752m2=−810000m2. The same.
Some books write the interval with the opposite sign, Δx2−(cΔt)2. The physics is the same. Read the sign convention of the question.
Three kinds of separation
A spacetime diagram with x across and c t up, and an event O at the origin. Two dashed orange lines at 45 degrees cross at O and form a cone. The region inside the upper cone is shaded green and labelled future of O, the region inside the lower cone is shaded green and labelled past of O, and the two side regions are grey and labelled elsewhere. A point A lies inside the upper cone, above O and a little to the right, and a point B lies in the right-hand grey region, to the right of O and only a little above it.
Timelike, s2>0. A body slower than light could be at both events. The proper time between them is Δt0=s2/c, the time on the clock of that body.
Lightlike, s2=0. Only light joins the events.
Spacelike, s2<0. Nothing can travel from one to the other. In some frame they happen at the same time, −s2 apart.
The two dashed lines through an event form its light cone. Event A, inside the upper cone, is in the future of O for every observer. Event B, outside the cone, is "elsewhere". Some observers say B comes after O, others before.
Causality. A cause must come before its effect in every frame. So only timelike or lightlike events can be cause and effect. For spacelike events, the order can flip, but no signal can join them, so no paradox follows.
The twin paradox
One twin stays on the Earth. The other flies at 0.8c to a star 4.0 light-years away and comes straight back. In the Earth's frame each leg takes 0.8ly/y4.0ly=5.0 years.
A spacetime diagram for the twin paradox, with distance in light-years across, from 0 to 5, and time in years up, from 0 to 10. A vertical blue line along x equal to 0 is the Earth twin, from 0 to 10 years, labelled Earth twin: ages 10.0 years. A red path goes from the origin up and to the right to a star at 4.0 light-years and 5.0 years, and then back up and to the left to the Earth at 10.0 years, making a bent line like a wide arrowhead. Each red leg is labelled 3.0 years on her clock. A dashed orange line at 45 degrees from the origin shows the path of light.
The Earth twin ages 10.0 years.
The traveller ages, on each leg, (5.0y)2−(4.0y)2=3.0 years. She ages 6.0 years in all.
Is this not symmetric? Each twin sees the other move. No. The Earth twin stays in one inertial frame. The traveller changes frame at the star, and her lines of simultaneity swing round as she turns. On the diagram her worldline is bent, and the Earth twin's is straight. Of all the worldlines between two events, the straight one has the longest proper time. That is why the traveller comes home younger.
Set Δx=600 m and cΔt=1000 m. Change the speed of S'. The separations change, but both intervals read 0.640. Now make Δx larger than cΔt. Can you find a speed that makes cΔt′ negative?
Practise with new numbers
Try it in Python
The program takes two events and looks at them from many frames. It prints the separations and the interval in each frame. Then it finds the frame in which the events are at the same time.
Common mistakes
Adding the squares. The interval is a difference: (cΔt)2−Δx2.
Reading tilted axes with a ruler. Their scale is stretched. Use the transformation.
Thinking the twin paradox is symmetric. Only the traveller changes frame.
Saying an effect can come before its cause. Only for spacelike events can the order flip, and those cannot be cause and effect.
Forgetting the sign convention. Check whether a book writes s2 with (cΔt)2 first or Δx2 first.
Remember these
Light moves at 45∘ on a spacetime diagram. A moving frame's axes lean in by tanθ=β.
Interval: s2=(cΔt)2−Δx2, the same in every frame.
Timelike, lightlike or spacelike, as s2 is positive, zero or negative.
Proper time: Δt0=s2/c.
The straight worldline between two events has the longest proper time.
Check yourself
Try each one on your own first. If you are stuck, open a hint. Then check with Show the answer.
Two events are Δx=900m and Δt=5.0μs apart. What kind of interval do they have?
The axes of a frame S' lean in by 30∘ on a diagram of S. How fast does S' move?
Can event A cause event B if the interval between them is spacelike?
In the twin paradox, why is the traveller's time shorter, not the Earth twin's?
References
OpenStax University Physics Volume 3, Chapter 5 Relativity, sections on the Lorentz transformation and spacetime.
Taylor and Wheeler, Spacetime Physics (second edition, 1992), on the interval, the light cone and the twin paradox.
Enroll free in Lorentz Transformations and Spacetime
Every lesson is open to read. Enrolling also lets you:
Mark lessons done and carry on where you stopped.
Take the tests of this lesson and its course.
Count the course towards the certificate for its chapter.