Adding velocities and the relativistic Doppler effect
Velocities add as u=(u′+v)/(1+u′v/c2)
Lesson 3 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
Speeds that will not add up
A rocket moves at 0.6c past the Earth. It fires a probe forwards at 0.8c, relative to the rocket. Galileo says the probe moves at 1.4c relative to the Earth. That cannot be right, because then the probe's light would leave it behind. What is the true speed?
The addition rule
Take the Lorentz transformation for two nearby events on the probe's worldline. Divide Δx′=γ(Δx−vΔt) by Δt′=γ(Δt−vΔx/c2). The γ cancels, and with u=Δx/Δt we get
u′=1−uv/c2u−v
Here u is the speed in S and u′ the speed in S'. The other way round,
u=1+u′v/c2u′+v
For the probe, u=1+0.480.8c+0.6c=0.946c. It is fast, but below c.
Light stays at c. Put u′=c: u=1+v/cc+v=c. Whatever the speed of the rocket, its headlight beam moves at c relative to the Earth. The rule has the second postulate built in.
Slow speeds. When u′v is far below c2, the bottom line is nearly 1, and u=u′+v as Galileo said.
A closing speed is not a velocity. On the Earth, two rockets moving apart at 0.8c each have a separation that grows at 1.6c. That is allowed, because no object moves at 1.6c. The speed of one rocket relative to the other is 1.641.6c=0.976c.
The sideways part (olympiad level). If the probe also has a part uy′ across the motion, then
uy=γ(1+ux′v/c2)uy′
The extra γ comes from time dilation. A particle that moves only sideways in S' is seen in S with ux=v and uy=uy′/γ.
The Doppler effect for light
For sound, the Doppler shift depends on the motion of the source and of the listener through the air. Light needs no medium. Only the relative speed of source and observer can matter. Let a source move straight away from you at v. In its own frame it emits a wave crest every T0.
Time dilation. In your frame the crests leave every γT0.
The growing distance. Between two crests the source moves vγT0 further away, so each crest has βγT0 further to travel.
The result. The crests arrive every T=γT0(1+β). This simplifies to
T=T01−β1+β
The wavelength grows by the same factor, and the frequency falls by it. For a source that comes closer, change the sign of β.
A graph of the ratio of the received wavelength to the emitted wavelength, from 0 to 3, against the speed of the source away from the observer as a fraction of c, from minus 0.8 to plus 0.8. Negative speeds mean the source comes closer. A blue curve, labelled relativity, rises from 0.33 at minus 0.8 through 1 at zero to 3 at plus 0.8, bending upwards. A dashed grey straight line, labelled one plus beta, rises from 0.2 to 1.8. A red point on the blue curve at plus 0.6 shows a ratio of exactly 2, and a second red point at minus 0.6 shows a ratio of 0.5.
Worked example. A hydrogen line of 656.3nm comes from a source moving away at 0.6c. Then 1.6/0.4=2, so we receive 1312.6nm, in the infrared.
Redshift. Astronomers write z=λ0λ−λ0. For slow sources z≈β, the rule A-Level and IB use for galaxies. At 0.1c the full formula gives z=0.106, so the slow rule is already about 5% out.
The transverse Doppler effect. Light received at right angles to the source's motion, in your frame, has its frequency lowered by γ. Sound has no such effect. It is pure time dilation, and it has been measured with fast-moving atoms.
Set v=0.6 and u′=0.8. Read the speed relative to the Earth. Now set u′=1, a light pulse. Can any choice of v make the probe pass c?
Practise with new numbers
Try it in Python
A ship fires a probe at 0.5c. The probe fires a second probe at 0.5c relative to itself, and so on, ten times. The program adds the speeds one at a time with the rule of this lesson.
Common mistakes
Adding speeds like Galileo. At high speed use u=(u′+v)/(1+u′v/c2).
Getting the sign of the bottom line wrong. It is 1+u′v/c2 when the speeds point the same way and are added.
Calling a closing speed a speed of an object. A separation may grow faster than c. No object moves faster than c.
Using the sound formula for light. Light depends only on the relative speed, and it has a transverse effect.
Swapping approach and recession. A source moving away gives a longer wavelength, a redshift.
Remember these
u=1+u′v/c2u′+v, and u′=1−uv/c2u−v.
Adding any speed to c gives c.
Receding source: λ=λ0(1+β)/(1−β). Approaching: swap the signs.
Redshift z=(λ−λ0)/λ0, and z≈β for slow sources.
Transverse Doppler: the frequency falls by γ.
Check yourself
Try each one on your own first. If you are stuck, open a hint. Then check with Show the answer.
Two spaceships move towards each other, each at 0.5c in the Earth's frame. How fast does one move in the frame of the other?
A rocket at 0.9c switches on its headlight. How fast does the light move relative to the Earth?
A source moving towards you at 0.6c emits light of 600nm. What wavelength do you receive?
Why is there no Doppler shift of sound at right angles to the motion, while light has one?
References
OpenStax University Physics Volume 3, Chapter 5 Relativity, sections on the relativistic velocity transformation and the Doppler effect for light.
Taylor and Wheeler, Spacetime Physics (second edition, 1992), on the addition of velocities and the Doppler shift.
Enroll free in Lorentz Transformations and Spacetime
Every lesson is open to read. Enrolling also lets you:
Mark lessons done and carry on where you stopped.
Take the tests of this lesson and its course.
Count the course towards the certificate for its chapter.