In 1944 Harold Ellingham drew the Gibbs energy of formation of many oxides against temperature on one sheet. The lines show, at a glance, which element can take oxygen from which oxide and at what temperature. This lesson teaches you to read the slopes, the kinks and the crossings.
about 25 min1 simulation1 practice question
Lesson 2 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
What is plotted
An Ellingham diagram plots ΔG∘ of formation, per mole of oxygen gas, against T. Over a range with no change of phase, ΔH∘ and ΔS∘ hardly change, so each line is nearly straight:
ΔG∘=ΔH∘−TΔS∘
The intercept at T=0 is ΔH∘. The slope is −ΔS∘.
An Ellingham diagram computed from standard data. The horizontal axis is the temperature from 300 K to 2300 K. The vertical axis is the standard Gibbs energy change in kJ per mole of oxygen gas, from minus 1100 to plus 100. Rising straight lines, from top to bottom: silver oxide (crossing zero near 466 K), copper(I) oxide, iron(II) oxide, zinc oxide, chromium(III) oxide, aluminium oxide and magnesium oxide. The line for 2C + O2 to 2CO falls from left to right and crosses the iron(II) oxide line near 1019 K, the zinc oxide line near 1263 K and the chromium(III) oxide line near 1489 K. The line for C + O2 to CO2 is almost flat near minus 394. The line for 2CO + O2 to 2CO2 rises and meets the two carbon lines near 980 K.
The lines of this chapter come from standard enthalpies and entropies at 298 K, in kJ per mole of oxygen gas with T in kelvin:
Real diagrams use high-temperature data, so their numbers differ a little, but the order of the lines and the crossings are close to these.
Reading the slopes
Metal lines rise. Solid metal and gas give a solid oxide. One mole of gas disappears, ΔS∘ is about −0.2kJ/K, and the slope is about +0.2kJ/K. That is why most metal lines are nearly parallel.
The C to CO line falls. One mole of oxygen gas gives two moles of CO gas. The entropy rises, so the slope is negative. Carbon becomes a better reducing agent the hotter it gets.
The C to CO₂ line is flat. One mole of gas gives one mole of gas, and ΔS∘ is close to zero.
The CO to CO₂ line rises. Three moles of gas give two.
Kinks at changes of phase
When the metal melts or boils, the entropy of the metal jumps up. The formation reaction then loses more entropy, ΔS∘ becomes more negative, and the line turns steeper. Boiling makes a big kink, because a gas has a lot of entropy. Zinc boils at 1180 K and magnesium at 1363 K, so their lines bend upward there. If the oxide melts or boils instead, the line turns less steep.
Reading a crossing
Rule. At a given temperature, an element whose line lies lower can reduce the oxide of any element whose line lies higher.
So an element low on the diagram (Mg, Al) is a strong reducing agent. An oxide high on the diagram (Ag2O, Cu2O) is easy to reduce.
The gap between the two lines at T is ΔG∘ of the reduction, per mole of oxygen gas. Where two lines cross, the gap is zero. Above the crossing the order flips. For carbon and iron(II) oxide:
−221−0.179T=−544+0.138T⇒T=0.317323=1019K
Above about 1019 K, carbon reduces iron(II) oxide to iron.
Choose ZnO and slide T upward. The reduction by carbon turns negative near 1263 K. Then choose Al₂O₃. The crossing is above 2300 K. Carbon could reduce alumina only at a temperature that no ordinary furnace reaches and at a ruinous cost.
The two carbon lines and the CO line
The two carbon lines and the CO line meet near 980 K.
Below about 980 K, the C to CO₂ line is lower. Carbon burns mainly to carbon dioxide, and the CO to CO₂ line lies below the C to CO line. So carbon monoxide is the better reducing agent there.
Above about 980 K, the C to CO line is the lowest. Carbon burns to carbon monoxide, and carbon itself is the better reducing agent.
That is the whole logic of the blast furnace, which the next lesson uses.
Practise with new numbers
Try it in Python
The program checks which of five oxides carbon can reduce at one temperature, and where each crossing lies.
Limits of the diagram
It gives the direction, not the rate. Many reductions that are allowed are slow until the solid is hot.
It assumes pure solids and gases at 1 bar. A metal dissolved in another metal, or a gas at low pressure, shifts the balance.
It says nothing about side products such as carbides.
Common mistakes
Reading the higher line as the stronger reducing agent. The lower line reduces the higher oxide.
Thinking every line rises. The C to CO line falls, because gas is made.
Forgetting the kink. Above the boiling point of a metal, its line is steeper.
Using a crossing to claim a fast reaction. The crossing only says the change becomes possible.
Remember these
Intercept: ΔH∘. Slope: −ΔS∘.
Lower line reduces higher oxide. The gap is ΔG∘ of the reduction.
C to CO falls; C to CO₂ is flat; CO to CO₂ rises. Carbon wins above about 980 K, CO below it.
Boiling of the metal makes the line steeper.
References
NCERT Chemistry Part I for Class 12 (2007 edition), Unit 6, the Ellingham diagram and its applications.
Atkins and others, Shriver and Atkins' Inorganic Chemistry, the chapter on oxidation and reduction, the section on the extraction of the elements.
Check yourself
Try each one on your own first. If you are stuck, open a hint. Then check with Show the answer.
Why do most metal oxide lines on an Ellingham diagram run nearly parallel?
Why does the line for 2C+O2→2CO slope downward?
At 1100 K, which line is lower: carbon to carbon monoxide, or iron(II) oxide? What does that mean?
What happens to the zinc line at 1180 K, and why?
Enroll free in Thermodynamics of Extraction: Ellingham Diagrams and Reduction
Every lesson is open to read. Enrolling also lets you:
Mark lessons done and carry on where you stopped.
Take the tests of this lesson and its course.
Count the course towards the certificate for its chapter.