Two clear solutions can look the same in a bottle. Add a few drops of sodium hydroxide, and one gives a blue jelly while the other gives a white one. This lesson sets out what sodium hydroxide and aqueous ammonia do to the common cations, and uses the solubility product to say when each hydroxide forms.
about 25 min1 simulation1 practice question
Lesson 2 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
Two reagents, two steps each
Most metal hydroxides do not dissolve in water. So when we add hydroxide ions to a solution of a metal ion, a solid often appears. We call this solid a precipitate. Its colour, and what happens when we add more reagent, tell us the cation.
We use two reagents:
Aqueous sodium hydroxide. Add a few drops, then add it in excess.
Aqueous ammonia. Add a few drops, then add it in excess.
With a few drops, both reagents give hydroxide ions. In excess, they behave differently. Excess sodium hydroxide dissolves an amphoteric hydroxide, one that reacts with acids and with bases. Excess ammonia dissolves a hydroxide whose metal forms an ammine complex, an ion with ammonia molecules bound to the metal.
Six test tubes after a few drops of sodium hydroxide solution, each labelled with the cation and the colour of its precipitate. Copper(II): pale blue. Iron(II): green, with a brown layer at the top where air touches it. Iron(III): red brown. Manganese(II): off-white, turning brown at the top. Zinc: white. Chromium(III): grey green.
What each cation does
These are the observations in the form A-Level, IB and IGCSE use. Indian books describe the same reactions in the group analysis.
Cation
A few drops of NaOH
Excess NaOH
Al3+
white ppt
dissolves
Zn2+
white ppt
dissolves
Cr3+
grey green ppt
dissolves, green
Cu2+
pale blue ppt
stays
Fe2+
green ppt
stays, browns in air
Fe3+
red brown ppt
stays
Mn2+
off-white ppt
stays, browns in air
Mg2+
white ppt
stays
Ca2+
white ppt
stays
"Ppt" is short for precipitate, and "stays" means it does not dissolve in excess.
Cation
A few drops of NH3
Excess NH3
Al3+
white ppt
stays
Zn2+
white ppt
dissolves
Cr3+
grey green ppt
stays
Cu2+
blue ppt
deep blue solution
Fe2+
green ppt
stays, browns in air
Fe3+
red brown ppt
stays
Mn2+
off-white ppt
stays, browns in air
Mg2+
white ppt
stays
Ca2+
no ppt
no ppt
Barium ions give no precipitate with either reagent at the usual concentrations. Ammonium ions give no precipitate either. Warm an ammonium salt with sodium hydroxide and ammonia gas comes off. It turns damp red litmus blue.
The equations
Amphoteric hydroxides in excess alkali: Al(OH)3+OH−→[Al(OH)4]− and Zn(OH)2+2OH−→[Zn(OH)4]2−.
Ammine complexes in excess ammonia: Cu(OH)2+4NH3→[Cu(NH3)4]2++2OH−, which is deep blue, and Zn(OH)2+4NH3→[Zn(NH3)4]2++2OH−, which is colourless.
Oxidation in air: 4Fe(OH)2+O2+2H2O→4Fe(OH)3. The green solid turns red brown, first at the top where air reaches it.
Why does zinc dissolve in excess ammonia while aluminium does not? Zinc forms a stable ammine complex. Aluminium does not, and ammonia is too weak a base to make the aluminate ion.
When does a hydroxide come down?
A hydroxide M(OH)n precipitates when the ionic product reaches the solubility product:
[Mn+][OH−]n=Ksp
We want the hydroxide ion concentration at that point, so
[OH−]=([Mn+]Ksp)1/n
Then pOH=−log[OH−] and pH=14−pOH at 298 K.
Take copper(II) ions at 0.010mol/dm3, with Ksp=2.2×10−20. Then [OH−]=2.2×10−18=1.5×10−9mol/dm3. The pOH is 8.83, so the copper hydroxide starts to form at pH 5.17.
Try each cation at the same concentration. Iron(III) hydroxide comes down in acid solution, near pH 2. Magnesium hydroxide needs a pH above 9. This is how a chemist separates iron from magnesium: she holds the pH between the two values.
Practise with new numbers
Try it in Python
The program stores what the two reagents do and names a cation from the observations.
Common mistakes
Mixing up zinc and aluminium. Both dissolve in excess sodium hydroxide. Only zinc dissolves in excess ammonia.
Calling the deep blue solution a precipitate. It is the dissolved ion [Cu(NH3)4]2+.
Forgetting the air. Iron(II) and manganese(II) hydroxides darken at the surface as they oxidise.
Forgetting the power n. For Fe(OH)3 the hydroxide concentration is cubed.
Remember these
Amphoteric, dissolve in excess sodium hydroxide: Al, Zn, Cr(III).
Ammine complexes, dissolve in excess ammonia: Cu (deep blue), Zn (colourless).
Colours: Cu pale blue, Fe(II) green, Fe(III) red brown, Cr(III) grey green, Mn(II) off-white.
Onset: [OH−]=(Ksp/c)1/n.
References
OpenStax Chemistry 2e, Chapter 15, section 15.1 on precipitation and dissolution, and section 15.2 on complex ions.
NCERT Chemistry Part II for Class 11, Unit 7, Equilibrium, on the solubility product.
Check yourself
Try each one on your own first. If you are stuck, open a hint. Then check with Show the answer.
A solution gives a white precipitate with a few drops of sodium hydroxide, and the precipitate dissolves in excess. With ammonia it gives a white precipitate that dissolves in excess. Name the cation.
Why does a green precipitate of iron(II) hydroxide turn brown at the top first?
Magnesium ions are at 0.010mol/dm3 and Ksp of Mg(OH)2 is 5.6×10−12. At what pH does the hydroxide start to form?
Which reagent, in excess, tells aluminium ions from zinc ions?
Enroll free in Identifying Ions and Gases: Flame Colours, Precipitates and Gas Tests
Every lesson is open to read. Enrolling also lets you:
Mark lessons done and carry on where you stopped.
Take the tests of this lesson and its course.
Count the course towards the certificate for its chapter.