For most of the last century, chemists cleaned up pollution after it was made. Green chemistry asks a better question: can we design the reaction so that the waste is never made? This lesson sets out the twelve principles that answer it, with real examples.
about 25 min1 simulation1 practice question
Lesson 1 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
Prevention is better than cleaning up
Think of a kitchen. You can cook carelessly and then spend an hour cleaning up, or you can plan the meal so that little mess is made. Chemical industry used to work like the careless cook. Rivers, air and soil were cleaned, at great cost, after the waste was made.
Green chemistry is the design of chemical products and processes that reduce or remove the use and making of hazardous substances. It was set out as twelve principles by Paul Anastas and John Warner in 1998.
A grid of twelve numbered boxes, the twelve principles of green chemistry. 1 prevent waste. 2 atom economy. 3 less hazardous syntheses. 4 safer chemicals. 5 safer solvents. 6 energy efficiency. 7 renewable feedstocks. 8 fewer derivatives. 9 catalysts. 10 design to degrade. 11 watch the process in real time. 12 safer to prevent accidents. The boxes are coloured in three groups: waste and atoms, safety, and energy and resources.
The twelve principles
Prevent waste. It is better not to make waste than to treat it.
Atom economy. Design a reaction so that as many atoms of the reactants as possible end up in the product.
Less hazardous syntheses. Use and make substances that are as little toxic as possible.
Safer chemicals. Design products that do their job and are as little toxic as possible.
Safer solvents and auxiliaries. Avoid solvents and separating agents where you can. Use safe ones where you must.
Energy efficiency. Run reactions near room temperature and pressure where possible.
Renewable feedstocks. Use raw materials from plants and waste, not from oil, where it makes sense.
Fewer derivatives. Avoid extra steps such as protecting and then freeing a group, because each step uses reagents and makes waste.
Catalysis. A catalyst is used again and again. A reagent used in a 1 : 1 ratio becomes waste.
Design for degradation. Products should break down into harmless substances after use.
Real-time analysis. Watch the process as it runs, so that a side reaction is caught before it makes waste.
Safer to prevent accidents. Choose substances and forms (a solution, not a dust or a gas) that are less likely to explode, burn or leak.
Examples you should know
Dry cleaning. Clothes were cleaned with tetrachloroethene, Cl2C=CCl2, a chlorinated solvent that pollutes ground water and may cause cancer. Now liquid carbon dioxide, with a suitable detergent, does the job. The carbon dioxide is recovered and used again (principle 5).
Bleaching paper. Chlorine was used to bleach wood pulp, and it made chlorinated organic compounds, some of them dioxins. Hydrogen peroxide with a suitable catalyst bleaches well, and its by-product is water: H2O2→H2O+O, the oxygen atom doing the bleaching (principles 3 and 4).
Ethanal from ethene. Ethanal, CH3CHO, was once made in several steps with stoichiometric oxidising agents. Now ethene is oxidised by oxygen in one step, in water, with palladium(II) and copper(II) chloride as catalysts. The yield is about 90 %:
CH2=CH2+O2→CH3CHO (written for one half of an O2 molecule for each ethanal: 2CH2=CH2+O2→2CH3CHO)
All the atoms of the reactants end in the product (principles 2 and 9).
Ibuprofen. The pain killer was first made in six steps, and less than half the mass of the reactants ended in the product. A newer three-step route with catalysts that are recovered uses about three quarters (principles 1, 2 and 9). You will work out both in the next lesson.
The E-factor
How much waste does a process make? The E-factor, introduced by Roger Sheldon, answers this:
E=mass of productmass of waste
Everything that goes in and does not leave as product counts as waste, solvent and washing water included, unless it is recovered and used again. An ideal process has E=0.
Industry
Typical E-factor
Oil refining
below 0.1
Bulk chemicals
below 1 to 5
Fine chemicals
5 to 50
Medicines
25 to over 100
Medicines have the largest E-factors. They are made in many steps, with much solvent, in small amounts.
Set an atom economy of 60 % and a yield of 80 %. The E-factor is about 1.08. Now push the yield to 100 %. The E-factor falls to 0.67, not to zero, because 40 % of the atoms of the reactants still end up in by-products. A good yield is not enough. The reaction itself must waste few atoms.
Try it in Python
The program works out the E-factor of one batch from its record.
Common mistakes
Thinking a high yield means a green process. A high yield with a poor atom economy still makes much waste.
Leaving the solvent out of the E-factor. It is often most of the waste.
Calling a catalyst waste. It is recovered and used again, so it counts only if it is lost.
Confusing prevention with treatment. Treating waste well is good. Not making it is better.
Remember these
Green chemistry designs out waste and hazard. Twelve principles (Anastas and Warner, 1998).
Examples: liquid carbon dioxide for dry cleaning; hydrogen peroxide for bleaching; ethanal from ethene in one catalytic step.
E=productwaste, solvents included. Medicines 25 to over 100, oil refining below 0.1.
References
Anastas, P. T. and Warner, J. C., Green Chemistry: Theory and Practice, Oxford University Press, 1998, Chapter 4.
Sheldon, R. A., The E factor 25 years on: the rise of green chemistry and sustainability, Green Chemistry, 2017.
NCERT Chemistry Part II for Class 11 (2006 edition), Unit 14, section 14.6 on green chemistry.
Check yourself
Try each one on your own first. If you are stuck, open a hint. Then check with Show the answer.
Which principle does a catalyst follow, and why is it greener than a reagent?
Why did dry cleaners change from tetrachloroethene to liquid carbon dioxide?
A batch uses 300 kg of materials and gives 25 kg of product. Nothing is recovered. What is the E-factor?
Why do medicines have much larger E-factors than bulk chemicals?
Enroll free in Green Chemistry: Atom Economy, Safer Solvents and Nanochemistry
Every lesson is open to read. Enrolling also lets you:
Mark lessons done and carry on where you stopped.
Take the tests of this lesson and its course.
Count the course towards the certificate for its chapter.