A reaction can give a yield of 100 % and still turn most of what goes in into waste. This lesson shows how to measure that waste with atom economy, how it combines with yield, and how real industrial routes have been redesigned to make less of it.
about 25 min1 simulation1 practice question
Lesson 2 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
Two ways to judge a reaction
A student makes 1,2-dibromoethane from ethene and bromine and gets a yield of 95 %. Another makes bromoethane from ethanol and gets 95 % too. Are the two equally good? Not at all. Look at what else each reaction makes.
Percentage yield compares what you got with what the equation allows:
%yield=theoretical massmass obtained×100
Atom economy compares the product with everything that went in, even with a perfect yield:
atom economy=∑M(reactants)M(wanted product)×100
Use the molar masses from the balanced equation, each times its coefficient.
Atom economy by type of reaction
Addition and rearrangement put every atom into the product. Their atom economy is 100 %. Example: CH2=CH2+Br2→CH2BrCH2Br.
Substitution swaps one group for another. The group that leaves is waste. Example: C2H5OH+HBr→C2H5Br+H2O, with an atom economy of 85.8 %.
Elimination removes a small molecule. Example: C2H5OH→C2H4+H2O, with an atom economy of 60.9 %.
A horizontal bar chart of the atom economy of six reactions, from 0 to 100 percent. Ethene and bromine to 1,2-dibromoethane, 100 percent. Ethene and hydrogen chloride to chloroethane, 100 percent. The three-step route to ibuprofen, 77 percent. Butane to maleic anhydride, 58 percent. Benzene to maleic anhydride, 44 percent. Ethanol to chloroethane with thionyl chloride, 39 percent. Addition reactions are at the top with full bars.
Set a product of 109 g/mol and a by-product of 18 g/mol, like bromoethane and water. The atom economy is 85.8 %. With a yield of 85 % the reaction mass efficiency (the mass of product over the mass of reactants) is only about 73 %.
Reaction mass efficiency
For reactants in their exact ratio, the mass of product for each kilogram of reactants is
RME=atom economy×yield
and the E-factor, without solvents, is RME1−1. If one reactant is in excess, the excess is waste too, and the RME is lower.
Real routes compared
Ibuprofen. The older route had six steps and used reagents such as aluminium chloride in large amounts. Its atom economy was about 40 %. The newer route has three steps:
C10H14+(CH3CO)2O→C12H16O+CH3COOH (with hydrogen fluoride as a catalyst that is recovered)
C12H16O+H2→C12H18O (with a nickel catalyst)
C12H18O+CO→C13H18O2 (with a palladium catalyst)
Add the reactants: 134.2+102.1+2.016+28.01=266.3g/mol. The product, ibuprofen, is 206.3g/mol. So the atom economy is 266.3206.3×100=77.5%. The only by-product, ethanoic acid, is recovered and sold.
Maleic anhydrideC4H2O3 (98.06g/mol), used for plastics, was made from benzene:
2C6H6+9O2→2C4H2O3+4CO2+4H2O
It is now made from butane, which loses no carbon as carbon dioxide:
2C4H10+7O2→2C4H2O3+8H2O
The benzene route has an atom economy of 44 % and the butane route 58 %. Butane is also less toxic than benzene, which causes cancer.
Try it in Python
The program works out the atom economy of a reaction from the formulas of its reactants and product.
Common mistakes
Leaving out the coefficients. Use the balanced equation: three moles of ethanol count three times.
Putting the by-product on top. Atom economy has the wanted product on top.
Mixing up yield and atom economy. Yield is about the experiment. Atom economy is about the equation.
Calling a catalyst a reactant. It does not appear in the overall equation.
Forgetting the excess reagent. It is waste if it is not recovered.
Remember these
Atom economy =M(product)/∑M(reactants)×100, from the balanced equation.
Addition and rearrangement: 100 %. Substitution and elimination: less.
RME=atom economy×yield for reactants in their exact ratio.
Try each one on your own first. If you are stuck, open a hint. Then check with Show the answer.
Why is the atom economy of an addition reaction always 100 %?
Ethanol (46.07g/mol) is dehydrated to ethene (28.05g/mol). What is the atom economy?
A reaction has an atom economy of 50 % and a yield of 80 %, with reactants in their exact ratio. What is the reaction mass efficiency, and the E-factor with no solvent?
Why does the butane route to maleic anhydride have a better atom economy than the benzene route?
Enroll free in Green Chemistry: Atom Economy, Safer Solvents and Nanochemistry
Every lesson is open to read. Enrolling also lets you:
Mark lessons done and carry on where you stopped.
Take the tests of this lesson and its course.
Count the course towards the certificate for its chapter.