A town full of retired people will have many deaths each year, even if its hospitals are excellent. Its crude death rate is high because of the ages of its people. A standardised rate asks a fairer question: what would the rate be if the town had the same mix of ages as a standard population?
about 30 min1 simulation1 practice question
Lesson 2 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
What you will be able to do
explain why two crude rates can give an unfair comparison;
calculate a rate for each group of a population;
calculate a standardised rate as a weighted average of the group rates, given a standard population.
Two towns of the same size
Seaview is a made-up seaside town where many people retire. Millbrook is a made-up town with a large university and many young families. Each town has 30000 people. Here are their crude death rates for one year.
Seaview: 450 deaths, so 30000450×1000=15.0 per thousand.
Millbrook: 234 deaths, so 30000234×1000=7.8 per thousand.
Is Seaview the less healthy town? Not necessarily. Older people are more likely to die than younger people, wherever they live. Seaview has a third of its people aged 65 and over. Millbrook has only a tenth.
Two side-by-side bar charts of the age mix of two made-up towns of 30 000 people each. Seaview has 20 percent under 25, 47 percent aged 25 to 64 and 33 percent aged 65 and over. Millbrook has 40 percent under 25, 50 percent aged 25 to 64 and 10 percent aged 65 and over. Each bar is labelled with its percentage.
The rate in each group
We split each town into age groups and find a rate for each one. This is called a group rate or an age-specific rate. Here is Seaview.
Age group
People
Deaths
under 25
6000
9
25 to 64
14 000
56
65 and over
10 000
385
Under 25: 60009×1000=1.5 per thousand.
25 to 64: 1400056×1000=4 per thousand.
65 and over: 10000385×1000=38.5 per thousand.
Millbrook's group rates are 2, 5 and 45 per thousand. So in every age group, Millbrook has the higher death rate. Its low crude rate came only from its young people.
Why we standardise
A crude rate mixes two things together: how healthy the people are, and how old they are. To compare health fairly, we must take away the effect of age. We do this by asking every town the same question: what would your death rate be if your people had the same mix of ages?
That fixed mix is the standard population. It is often the age mix of the whole country, given as percentages or as numbers per thousand.
How to standardise
A standardised rate is a weighted average of the group rates. The weights are the sizes of the groups in the standard population.
standardised rate=∑w∑rw
Here r is a group rate and w is the size of that group in the standard population.
The Greek letter ∑ (sigma) means "add up over all the groups". When the standard is given in percentages, the bottom line is 100.
Here the standard population has 30% under 25, 50% aged 25 to 64, and 20% aged 65 and over.
Age group
Seaview rate
Standard (%)
under 25
1.5
30
25 to 64
4
50
65 and over
38.5
20
Multiply each group rate by its standard weight.1.5×30=45, 4×50=200 and 38.5×20=770.
Add the products.45+200+770=1015.
Divide by the total of the weights.1001015=10.15 deaths per thousand.
Seaview's standardised death rate is 10.15 per thousand. Its crude rate was 15.0. Most of its high crude rate came from its age mix, not from poor health.
If the standard is given per thousand, for example 300, 500 and 200 people in every 1000, divide by 1000 instead. The answer is the same.
The crude rate is a weighted average too
Here is a useful fact. The crude rate is also a weighted average of the group rates, but its weights are the town's own people.
The products are 1.5×6000=9000, 4×14000=56000 and 38.5×10000=385000. They add up to 450000.
30000450000=15.0
So the two rates differ only in their weights. The crude rate uses the town's own age mix. The standardised rate uses the standard age mix.
Practise with new numbers
Try it in Python
The program finds the crude rate, the three group rates and the standardised rate of Seaview.
Your turn.
The usual mistakes
Taking a plain average of the group rates.31.5+4+38.5 gives every group the same weight. The groups are not the same size, so use the standard weights.
Using the town's own people as the weights. That gives the crude rate back again.
Using the deaths as the weights. The weights are numbers of people in the standard population.
Dividing by the wrong total. Divide by 100 for percentages, or by 1000 for numbers per thousand.
Remember these
Group rate =people in the groupevents in the group×1000.
Standardised rate =∑w∑rw, where r is a group rate and w its standard weight.
Crude rate: the town's own weights. Standardised rate: the standard weights.
Standardising takes away the effect of a different age mix.
Check yourself
Try each one on your own first. If you are stuck, open a hint. Then check with Show the answer.
A town has excellent hospitals but a high crude death rate. Give one likely reason.
In a town, the death rate is 3 per thousand for people under 65 and 40 per thousand for people aged 65 and over. The standard population has 80% under 65. Find the standardised death rate.
Millbrook's group rates are 2, 5 and 45 per thousand. Use the standard 30%, 50% and 20% to find its standardised death rate.
In a town, 72 people died out of 1600 people aged 65 and over. Find the group rate.
A standard population has 250, 450 and 300 people in every 1000 in three age groups. A town's group rates are 2, 6 and 40 per thousand. Find its standardised rate.
Enroll free in Crude and Standardised Rates
Every lesson is open to read. Enrolling also lets you:
Mark lessons done and carry on where you stopped.
Take the tests of this lesson and its course.
Count the course towards the certificate for its chapter.