Now we put the two kinds of rate to work. A crude rate says what really happens in a population. A standardised rate says how one population compares with another once their age mix is the same. This lesson draws conclusions from both, and uses rates to count the births, deaths or accidents to expect.
about 30 min1 simulation1 practice question
Lesson 3 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
What you will be able to do
form a conclusion about one or more populations from their crude and standardised rates;
choose the right rate for a question;
use a rate to find the total number of events in a population or in one group of it.
Reading the two rates together
Here are the rates of Seaview and Millbrook from the last lesson.
Seaview: crude 15.0, standardised 10.15 per thousand.
Millbrook: crude 7.8, standardised 12.1 per thousand.
Grouped bar chart of death rates per thousand for Seaview (plain bars) and Millbrook (hatched bars). In the three age groups the rates are 1.5 and 2 under 25, 4 and 5 for ages 25 to 64, and 38.5 and 45 for 65 and over. Two more pairs of bars show the crude rates, 15.0 and 7.8, and the standardised rates, 10.15 and 12.1. Every bar is labelled with its value.
What can we say?
The crude rates. Seaview has the higher crude rate. Out of every 1000 people who live there, more die in a year.
The reason. Seaview has a much larger share of older people, and older people die more often.
The standardised rates. After taking away the effect of age, Seaview has the lower rate. A person of a given age is less likely to die in Seaview than in Millbrook.
The conclusion. Seaview is the healthier town for people of the same age. Its high crude rate is caused by its age mix.
A good conclusion always says which rate it comes from and why the two rates differ.
Which rate answers which question?
How many funerals, hospital beds or nursery places will a town need? Use the crude rate, or the group rates, with the town's real people. These count what will really happen.
Is one town healthier, or safer, than another? Use the standardised rates, found with the same standard population.
Has a town become healthier over 20 years, while its people grew older? Standardise both years with the same standard.
Two standardised rates can only be compared when they use the same standard population. A rate found with a young standard and a rate found with an old standard are not comparable.
When the standard population is the whole country, there is one more comparison. If a town's standardised rate is below the country's crude rate, then the town's people die less often than the country's people of the same ages.
Counting events from a rate
A rate can be turned back into a number of events. We multiply the rate by the number of thousands of people.
number of events=1000rate×population
A whole population. A town of 64000 people has a crude birth rate of 11.5 per thousand. It expects 100011.5×64000=736 births in a year.
One group. In a district, the accident rate for drivers aged 17 to 24 is 18.5 per thousand drivers. There are 3200 such drivers. They expect 100018.5×3200=59.2, so about 59 accidents.
An expected number need not be a whole number. It is an average for a typical year, so we often round it.
A missing group
A crude rate can also find what is missing. A made-up town of 25000 people has a crude death rate of 9.6 per thousand.
Deaths in the whole town.10009.6×25000=240 deaths.
The groups we know. 30 deaths under 40 and 63 deaths aged 40 to 64.
The missing group.240−30−63=147 deaths among people aged 65 and over.
Practise with new numbers
Try it in Python
The program uses Seaview's group rates to forecast its deaths next year, when its age groups have slightly different numbers of people.
Your turn.
The usual mistakes
Saying a high crude rate means poor health. Look at the age mix first, or at the standardised rate.
Comparing standardised rates found with different standards. They answer different questions.
Using a standardised rate to count real events. The standardised rate describes a made-up population with the standard mix. To count real deaths, use the real people and the real rates.
Dividing by 100 instead of 1000. A rate per thousand times a population, divided by 1000.
Remember these
Events =1000rate×population, for a whole population or for one group.
Crude rates count what happens. Standardised rates compare health or safety fairly.
A conclusion names the rate it uses and explains why the rates differ.
Compare standardised rates only when they share one standard population.
Check yourself
Try each one on your own first. If you are stuck, open a hint. Then check with Show the answer.
Town P has a crude death rate of 12.4 and a standardised rate of 9.1 per thousand. Town Q has 8.2 and 10.6. Which town is healthier for people of the same age, and why does Town P have the higher crude rate?
A town of 52000 people has a crude birth rate of 12.5 per thousand. How many births does it expect in a year?
A council plans the number of places in its nursery schools. Should it use the crude birth rate or a standardised birth rate?
A town of 18000 people has a crude death rate of 10 per thousand. There were 25 deaths among people under 30 and 55 deaths among people aged 30 to 59. How many deaths were there among people aged 60 and over?
Asha standardises the death rate of her town with the age mix of her country. Leo standardises the rate of his town with the age mix of the whole world. Can they compare their two answers? Why?
Enroll free in Crude and Standardised Rates
Every lesson is open to read. Enrolling also lets you:
Mark lessons done and carry on where you stopped.
Take the tests of this lesson and its course.
Count the course towards the certificate for its chapter.