Drop an iron nail into blue copper sulfate solution and the nail turns pink-brown, because the more reactive metal pushes the other out. The halogens play the same game. We find out who wins, what you see, and why.
about 25 min1 simulation1 practice question
Lesson 2 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
A fight between halogens
A more reactive metal can take the place of a less reactive metal in a solution of its salt. You saw this with zinc and copper sulfate. The halogens do the same. A more reactive halogen displaces a less reactive halogen from a solution of its halide.
The order of reactivity is chlorine, then bromine, then iodine, with chlorine the most reactive of the three. This is the order that you met in the last lesson.
The experiment
You need a solution of each halogen in water (chlorine water, bromine water and a solution of iodine) and a solution of each potassium halide (potassium chloride, potassium bromide and potassium iodide). Mix a few drops of each halogen with each halide in a test tube, and look for a colour change.
A grid of nine results for the displacement tests. The rows are chlorine water, bromine water and iodine solution. The columns are potassium chloride, potassium bromide and potassium iodide solutions. Chlorine water gives no reaction with potassium chloride, an orange solution with potassium bromide and a brown solution with potassium iodide. Bromine water gives no reaction with potassium chloride or potassium bromide and a brown solution with potassium iodide. Iodine solution gives no reaction with any of the three. The three cells that show a reaction lie above the diagonal.
Read the results like this:
Chlorine water with potassium bromide. The solution turns orange. Bromine has been made.
Chlorine water with potassium iodide. The solution turns brown. Iodine has been made.
Bromine water with potassium iodide. The orange solution turns brown. Iodine has been made.
Bromine water with potassium chloride. There is no change. Bromine cannot displace chlorine.
Iodine solution with potassium chloride or potassium bromide. There is no change. Iodine is the least reactive of the three.
Notice the pattern in the picture. The three reactions lie on one side of a diagonal. A halogen only displaces a halogen that is below it in the group.
Why does it happen?
The halogen that is more reactive has a greater tendency to gain an electron and form a negative ion. A chlorine atom is smaller than a bromine atom, so its outer shell is closer to the nucleus. It attracts an extra electron more strongly. When chlorine meets bromide ions, chlorine takes the electrons, and bromine is set free as an element.
The potassium ions do not change. They are spectator ions, so we leave them out. The ionic equation shows only what changes.
Cl2(aq)+2Br−(aq)→2Cl−(aq)+Br2(aq)
Check that the equation is balanced for atoms and for charge. There are two chlorine atoms and two bromine atoms on each side. The charge is 2− on each side. In this reaction chlorine is the oxidising agent. It takes electrons from the bromide ions, which are oxidised. You will use these words again in the chapter on electrolysis and redox.
Two moles of potassium bromide need only one mole of chlorine, because each chlorine molecule takes two electrons.
Predicting more reactions
Use the order of reactivity to predict a reaction you have not seen.
Fluorine is more reactive than chlorine, so fluorine would displace chlorine, bromine and iodine from their salts.
Astatine is less reactive than iodine, so astatine would displace nothing. In fact chlorine, bromine and iodine would all displace astatine from an astatide.
Chlorine is not displaced by bromine. If a question lists a mixture of bromine water and potassium chloride, the answer is no reaction.
Practise with new numbers
Try it in Python
The program lists the nine tests of the picture and says what happens in each.
Common mistakes
Letting a halogen displace one that is above it. Bromine does not displace chlorine.
Forgetting the 2 in the equation. It is 2KBr and 2Br−, because bromine is Br2.
Naming the colour of the wrong halogen. An orange solution means bromine. A brown solution means iodine.
Leaving the spectator ions in the ionic equation. The K+ ions do not change, so they are left out.
Mixing up the reactivity order with Group I. Here the top of the group is the most reactive.
Remember these
A more reactive halogen displaces a less reactive halogen from a solution of its halide.