No real crystal is perfect. Some sites are empty, some ions sit in the wrong place, and some crystals do not even follow their own formula. These small faults change the colour, the density and the conductivity of a solid. We meet the point defects and do the arithmetic of non-stoichiometric compounds such as Fe0.95O.
Lesson 2 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
Why crystals have defects
A crystal grows fast from a melt or a solution, and particles get trapped in wrong places. Heat also makes defects: at any temperature above absolute zero, a few ions gain enough energy to leave their sites. A defect costs energy, but it raises the disorder, the entropy, of the crystal. So at equilibrium a crystal always holds some defects, and more at a higher temperature.
A defect that involves one site, or a few, is a point defect. Line defects (dislocations) and plane defects exist too, but here we study point defects only. There are three groups: stoichiometric, impurity and non-stoichiometric defects.
Four small square grids of positive ions (small purple circles) and negative ions (large green circles), each showing one defect. Schottky: one positive and one negative site are empty, marked by dashed squares. Frenkel: a positive ion has left its site, which is empty, and sits in a gap between the ions. Impurity: a doubly charged ion, drawn in orange and marked 2+, sits on a positive site, and the positive site next to it is empty. F-centre: a negative site is empty and holds an electron, marked e.
Stoichiometric defects
These leave the formula unchanged.
Vacancy defect (in an element): some lattice sites are empty. The density falls.
Interstitial defect (in an element): some atoms sit in the gaps between sites. The density rises.
In an ionic crystal, charge must stay balanced, so the defects come in matched sets.
Schottky defect. Equal numbers of cations and anions are missing. For AB, one A+ and one B− vacancy make a pair. The density falls. It is found in highly ionic salts whose ions are of similar size: NaCl, KCl, CsCl, AgBr. In NaCl at room temperature there are about 106 Schottky pairs in each cm3, against about 1022 ions.
Frenkel defect. An ion, usually the smaller cation, leaves its site and moves into an interstitial site. One vacancy and one interstitial ion form the pair. The density does not change. It is found when the ions differ a lot in size: ZnS, AgCl, AgBr, AgI. Frenkel defects are also called dislocation defects in some books.
Silver bromide shows both. Its small Ag+ ion moves into gaps easily.
Impurity defects
Add a little SrCl2 to molten NaCl and let it crystallise. Each Sr2+ takes the site of one Na+. To keep the charge balanced, a second Na+ site stays empty. So each strontium ion makes one cation vacancy. The same happens with CdCl2 in AgCl.
Example.NaCl holds 1.0×10−4 mol of SrCl2 for each mole of NaCl. The vacancies in one mole are 1.0×10−4×6.022×1023=6.0×1019. These vacancies let the ions move, so doped crystals conduct better.
Non-stoichiometric defects
Some crystals do not follow a simple whole-number formula.
Metal excess, by anion vacancies. Heat NaCl in sodium vapour. Sodium atoms settle on the surface and lose an electron each. The Na+ ions join the crystal, and chloride ions move out to meet them. Each electron goes into an empty anion site. An electron trapped in an anion vacancy is an F-centre, from the German Farbe, colour. The F-centres absorb visible light and colour the crystal: NaCl turns yellow, KCl violet and LiCl pink. The crystal is now Na1+δCl, with a little extra metal.
Metal excess, by extra cations. White zinc oxide turns yellow when heated. It loses oxygen:
ZnOheatZn2++21O2+2e−
The Zn2+ ions and the electrons sit in interstitial sites. The crystal is Zn1+δO. It turns white again on cooling.
Metal deficiency. Iron(II) oxide is never exactly FeO. A typical sample is Fe0.95O. Some Fe2+ sites are empty, and some Fe2+ ions have become Fe3+ to keep the charge balanced. For every empty site, two Fe2+ become Fe3+. NiO and FeS behave in the same way.
The arithmetic of Fe0.95O
Let b be the amount of Fe3+ in one formula unit. Then 0.95−b is Fe2+. The positive charge must equal the 2 of the oxide ion:
2(0.95−b)+3b=2⇒b=0.10
So Fe2+=0.85 and Fe3+=0.10. The share of iron that is Fe3+ is 0.950.10=10.5%. The empty iron sites are 1−0.95=0.05 per oxide ion. Check: two Fe3+ for each empty site, 2×0.05=0.10.
How many defects? (olympiad depth)
Making a Schottky pair costs an enthalpy ΔH per mole of pairs. The number n of pairs among N ion pairs at equilibrium is
Nn≈e−ΔH/2RT
The 2 appears because a pair makes two vacancies, which can sit anywhere independently. Take ΔH=200kJ/mol. At 300K the fraction is e−40.1=4×10−18. At 1000K it is e−12.03=6×10−6. Defects multiply with temperature.
Set ΔH=200kJ/mol. Move from 300K to 1000K. The curve climbs about 12 powers of ten.
Practise with new numbers
Try it in Python
The program finds the share of Fe3+ in iron oxides of different compositions, the vacancies made by a doping, and the fraction of Schottky pairs at two temperatures.
Common mistakes
Saying a Frenkel defect lowers the density. No ion leaves the crystal, so the density stays the same.
Saying a Schottky defect breaks the formula. Equal numbers of cations and anions are missing, so the formula is unchanged.
Counting two vacancies for each Sr2+. The strontium ion fills one of the two sites itself, so it leaves one vacancy.
Mixing up the colour of an F-centre and of the metal. The colour comes from electrons trapped in anion vacancies, not from metal atoms.
Taking the empty-site share as the Fe3+ share. Each empty site makes two Fe3+ ions.
Remember these
Schottky: cation and anion vacancies in pairs, density falls. Frenkel: an ion moves into a gap, density unchanged.
One M2+ impurity in a M+ salt makes one cation vacancy.
Metal excess: F-centres (electrons in anion vacancies) or extra cations in gaps, as in hot ZnO.
Metal deficiency: FexO with x<1, balanced by Fe3+. Fe3+ per formula =2−2x.
Equilibrium fraction of Schottky pairs: e−ΔH/2RT.
Check yourself
Try each one on your own first. If you are stuck, open a hint. Then check with Show the answer.
Which defect would you expect in AgCl, and why?
A crystal of KCl is heated in potassium vapour and turns violet. Explain the colour.
In Fe0.90O, how many Fe3+ ions are there in each formula unit?
Does a Schottky defect make a crystal of NaCl a better or a worse conductor? Why?
Why is zinc oxide yellow when hot and white when cold?
References
OpenStax, Chemistry 2e, Chapter 10, section 10.6, on defects in crystals.
Atkins, Physical Chemistry, the chapter on solids, for the equilibrium number of defects. NCERT, Chemistry Part I for Class XII, Unit 1, editions before 2023.
Enroll free in Ionic Structures, Defects and Properties of Solids
Every lesson is open to read. Enrolling also lets you:
Mark lessons done and carry on where you stopped.
Take the tests of this lesson and its course.
Count the course towards the certificate for its chapter.