Reagents and conditions: why the same reactants can give different products
Ethanol and hot concentrated sulphuric acid can give a gas or a liquid. The temperature decides which. This lesson sets out the main reagents of organic chemistry and the conditions that steer each one, so that you can write the right product every time.
about 25 min1 simulation1 practice question
Lesson 1 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
One flask, two products
Heat ethanol with concentrated sulphuric acid. What do you get? It depends on the temperature.
At 443 K the acid removes water from each ethanol molecule. Ethene, a gas, comes off. This is elimination.
At 413 K, with ethanol in excess, two ethanol molecules join and lose one water. Ethoxyethane, a liquid ether, forms. This is substitution.
C2H5OH→CH2=CH2+H2O at 443 K
2C2H5OH→C2H5OC2H5+H2O at 413 K
Two pairs of arrows that start from one compound. Top: ethanol with concentrated sulphuric acid. At 443 K the arrow goes to ethene and water, labelled elimination. At 413 K, with ethanol in excess, the arrow goes to ethoxyethane and water, labelled substitution. Bottom: bromoethane with potassium hydroxide. In water, warm, the arrow goes to ethanol, labelled substitution. In ethanol, hot, the arrow goes to ethene, labelled elimination.
So the reagent is only half of the story. The other half is the condition: the temperature, the solvent, the catalyst, light or dark, and how long you heat. A chemist who plans a synthesis writes both above the arrow.
Five pairs to know
Each pair below starts from the same reactants. Only the condition changes.
Bromoethane and potassium hydroxide. In water, warm: substitution gives ethanol. In ethanol, hot: elimination gives ethene. Water favours the hydroxide ion as a nucleophile. Ethanol, as solvent, favours it as a base.
A primary alcohol and acidified potassium dichromate. Distil the product off as it forms: you get the aldehyde. Heat under reflux: the aldehyde stays in the flask and goes on to the carboxylic acid.
Methylbenzene and chlorine. With iron(III) chloride in the dark, the ring is substituted: 1-chloro-2-methylbenzene and 1-chloro-4-methylbenzene form. With light or heat and no catalyst, the side chain is substituted (chloromethylbenzene, also called benzyl chloride).
Propene and hydrogen bromide. With no peroxide, 2-bromopropane forms (Markovnikov addition). With an organic peroxide, 1-bromopropane forms. This peroxide effect works for HBr only.
An alkene and potassium manganate(VII). Cold, dilute and alkaline: a diol forms (two OH groups). Hot, concentrated and acidified: the C=C bond breaks, and ketones or acids form.
Reflux means boiling with a condenser fitted upright, so that the vapour condenses and runs back. Nothing escapes, and the mixture can be heated for a long time.
The toolkit
These reagents do most of the work in the routes of this chapter. Learn the job of each one.
Reagent
Condition
Job
KCN
ethanol, reflux
RX to RCN
NaOH(aq)
warm
RX to ROH
KOH
ethanol, hot
RX to alkene
NH3
ethanol, sealed tube
RX to amine
PCl5 or SOCl2
room temperature
ROH to RCl
conc. H2SO4
443 K
ROH to alkene
PCC
CH2Cl2
1° ROH to RCHO
K2Cr2O7, H+
reflux
1° ROH to RCOOH
NaBH4
water or ethanol
C=O to CH-OH
LiAlH4
dry ether
reduces RCOOH and RCN
H3O+
heat
nitrile to acid
H2, Ni
heat
C=C and C≡N reduced
Two notes. PCC is pyridinium chlorochromate, a mild oxidant that stops at the aldehyde. NaBH4 reduces aldehydes and ketones but leaves esters, acids and C=C alone. LiAlH4 is stronger: it reduces acids and esters to primary alcohols, and nitriles and amides to amines. It reacts violently with water, so it is used in dry ether.
Kinds of reaction
Every arrow in a route is one of a few kinds. Name the kind and you know what the reagent must be.
Substitution: one group replaces another (RBr to ROH).
Addition: two molecules join across a double bond (alkene to haloalkane).
Elimination: a small molecule leaves and a double bond forms (alcohol to alkene).
Oxidation: the carbon gains bonds to oxygen or loses hydrogen (alcohol to aldehyde).
Reduction: the opposite (ketone to alcohol).
Hydrolysis: water breaks a bond, often with acid or alkali (nitrile to acid, ester to acid).
Condensation: two molecules join and lose a small one such as water (acid and alcohol to ester).
How much product?
A route is judged by its product. The percentage yield is the mass you get, ma, over the mass the equation allows, mt (the theoretical mass):
yield=mtma×100%
Set 20 g and 70 %. Benzene gives the largest mass of product, because a nitro group adds 45 g/mol to every mole. Ethanol to ethanal gives slightly less mass than you started with, because two hydrogen atoms leave.
Practise with new numbers
Try it in Python
The program finds the theoretical and actual mass of product for three reactions of this lesson.
Common mistakes
Writing a product without its condition. Ethanol and sulphuric acid give ethene at 443 K and the ether at 413 K.