Stack marbles in a tray and they settle into the hollows of the layer below. There are two ways to stack the third layer, and they give the two close packed structures of metals. Close packing leaves two kinds of hole, and small ions sit in them. We count the holes, find their size and use the radius ratio to predict where an ion goes.
about 35 min1 simulation2 practice questions
Lesson 3 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
Packing in one and two dimensions
Put equal spheres in a row, touching. Each touches 2 others. Now put rows side by side. There are two ways.
Square packing. The spheres of the second row sit right beside those of the first. Each sphere touches 4 others. A lot of space is left.
Hexagonal close packing in a layer. The second row sits in the dips of the first. Each sphere touches 6 others, in a hexagon. This fills the plane best.
Stack square layers right on top of each other and you get simple cubic, with 52.4% of space filled. Close packing starts from hexagonal layers.
Two ways to stack close packed layers
Call the first hexagonal layer A. It has two sets of hollows, which we call B and C. The second layer can sit only in one set, say B. It cannot fill both, because the B and C hollows are too close together.
Now the third layer has a choice.
It can sit right above layer A. The order is ABABAB. This is hexagonal close packing, hcp. Magnesium, zinc, titanium and cobalt are hcp.
It can sit over the C hollows, which no layer has covered yet. The order is ABCABC. This is cubic close packing, ccp. Look at the stack along a body diagonal and it is the face-centred cubic lattice. So ccp and fcc are the same structure. Copper, silver, gold, aluminium and nickel are ccp.
Top views of close packed layers of spheres. On the left, layer A is drawn as blue circles in a hexagonal pattern; the hollows of one kind are marked B with orange dots and the hollows of the other kind are marked C with green dots. In the middle, a second layer sits in the B hollows. On the right, two stacks are drawn from the side: A B A B, labelled hexagonal close packing (hcp), and A B C A B C, labelled cubic close packing (ccp), which is the face-centred cubic lattice.
In both, each sphere touches 6 in its own layer, 3 above and 3 below. So the coordination number is 12, and both fill 74.0% of space. Metals such as iron, sodium, potassium, chromium and tungsten take the bcc structure, which is not close packed.
The hcp unit cell
The usual cell of hcp is a hexagonal prism. It holds 12 corner atoms, each shared by 6 prisms, 2 face-centre atoms on the top and bottom, each shared by 2, and 3 atoms inside. So
Z=12×61+2×21+3=6
For touching spheres, a=2r, and the height is c=38a=1.633a. The volume of the prism is the area of its hexagon, 233a2, times c. Put these in, and the packing efficiency is 74.0% again. Real hcp metals have c/a near 1.633: magnesium has 1.624.
Voids: the holes between the spheres
Close packed spheres leave two kinds of hole.
A tetrahedral void sits under one sphere of the next layer, above three spheres of this layer. Its four neighbours sit at the corners of a tetrahedron.
An octahedral void sits between three spheres of one layer and three of the next, turned by 60∘. Its six neighbours sit at the corners of an octahedron.
Two holes between close packed spheres. On the left, a tetrahedral void: three spheres in a triangle with a fourth sphere on top, and a small red sphere in the hole at the centre, touching all four. On the right, an octahedral void: four spheres in a square with one above and one below the centre, and a larger red sphere at the centre, touching all six. Labels give the largest sphere that fits: 0.225 r in the tetrahedral void and 0.414 r in the octahedral void.
How many voids are there? In any close packing of N spheres there are N octahedral voids and 2N tetrahedral voids. We can check this in the fcc cell, which holds 4 atoms:
Octahedral voids: one at the body centre, and one at the middle of each of the 12 edges, shared by 4 cells. That is 1+12×41=4, one for each atom.
Tetrahedral voids: each corner of the cube, with the three face centres next to it, makes a small tetrahedron. Its void lies on the body diagonal, a quarter of the way in from the corner. That is 8 voids, all inside the cell, two for each atom.
How large is a void?
Let the packed spheres have radius R. Let r be the radius of the largest sphere that fits in a void without pushing them apart.
Octahedral void. Take the square of four spheres around the void. Its side is 2R and its diagonal is 22R. The diagonal holds 2R+2r. So 2R+2r=22R, and r=(2−1)R=0.414R.
Tetrahedral void. The distance from the centre of a tetrahedron to a corner is 83 times the edge. The edge is 2R, so R+r=23R. We want r, so r=0.225R.
The tetrahedral void is smaller, though there are twice as many.
The formula from the voids
The ions of a salt can be pictured as large anions in close packing with small cations in the voids. Count the voids, and you have the formula.
Example: oxide ions form an hcp lattice, and Al3+ ions fill two thirds of the octahedral voids. For N oxide ions there are N octahedral voids, so 32N aluminium ions. The ratio is Al:O=32:1=2:3. The formula is Al2O3, the mineral corundum. The charges agree: 2×(+3)+3×(−2)=0.
Another: atoms Y form a ccp lattice and atoms X fill a third of the tetrahedral voids. For N atoms of Y there are 2N tetrahedral voids, so 32N atoms of X. The formula is X2Y3.
The radius ratio rule
A cation fits snugly in a void when it touches all its anion neighbours. If it is smaller than the void, it rattles, and the structure becomes unstable. If it is larger, it pushes the anions apart, which is fine. So each coordination needs a ratio r+/r− at least as large as the void:
0.155 to 0.225: coordination number 3, triangular planar;
0.225 to 0.414: coordination number 4, tetrahedral;
0.414 to 0.732: coordination number 6, octahedral;
0.732 and above: coordination number 8, cubic.
The limit 0.732 is the void at the centre of a simple cube of anions: 3(2R)=2R+2r, so r=(3−1)R=0.732R. The limit 0.155 is the hole in a triangle of three anions: r=(32−1)R.
For NaCl, r+=102pm and r−=181pm. The ratio is 0.564, so the rule gives 6, which is right. The rule often fails, though. Ions are not hard spheres, bonds have some covalent character, and radii depend on the coordination number. Lithium iodide has a ratio near 0.35, yet it has the 6 coordinate rock salt structure. Treat the rule as a first guess.
Start with NaCl: 102pm and 181pm. Lower the cation to 60pm. The rule now predicts tetrahedral coordination.
Practise with new numbers
Try it in Python
The program places spheres around an octahedral and a tetrahedral void, finds the largest sphere that fits by geometry, and then writes formulas from the share of voids that cations fill.
Common mistakes
Saying hcp and ccp pack differently. Both fill 74.0% of space and both have coordination number 12. Only the order of the layers differs.
Mixing up the numbers of voids. For N spheres: N octahedral and 2N tetrahedral.
Mixing up the sizes. The tetrahedral void is the smaller one, 0.225R. The octahedral void is 0.414R.
Treating bcc as close packed. It fills 68.0% and its coordination number is 8.
Trusting the radius ratio rule always. It is a first guess. Many salts break it.
Remember these
Close packed layers: ABAB is hcp, ABCABC is ccp, which is fcc. Coordination number 12, 74.0% filled.
The hcp cell holds 6 atoms, with ideal c/a=1.633.
N spheres make N octahedral and 2N tetrahedral voids.