A drop of ink spreads in still water, but it would take years to cross a metre. This lesson compares the ways substances cross a cell membrane: simple diffusion, facilitated diffusion through channels and carriers, and active transport with energy, and shows why a plant also needs bulk flow.
about 25 min1 simulation1 practice question
Lesson 1 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
Short trips and long trips
Put a drop of ink in a glass of still water. It spreads slowly by diffusion, the random movement of particles from where they are more concentrated to where they are less. Over the width of a cell, diffusion is fast. Over the height of a plant, it is hopeless.
The time to diffuse a distance x is about t=2Dx2, where D is the diffusion coefficient. For a sugar in water, D is about 10−9m2/s.
Across a cell, 50μm: t=2×10−9m2/s(5×10−5m)2=1.25s.
Up a plant, 1m: t=2×10−9m2/s(1m)2=5×108s, about 16 years.
Doubling the distance makes the time four times longer. So a plant uses diffusion for short trips, and bulk flow (mass flow) for long ones. In bulk flow, a whole body of fluid moves together, pushed or pulled by a difference in pressure. The xylem and the phloem carry sap this way. This course follows water from the soil into the root. The next course follows it up the plant.
Simple diffusion
Small molecules that dissolve in lipids, such as oxygen and carbon dioxide, cross the membrane directly. They move from high to low concentration. No energy is used, and no protein is needed.
The rate depends on the gradient of concentration, the permeability of the membrane, the temperature and the distance. Large molecules and charged ions cross the lipid layer very slowly.
Facilitated diffusion
Ions and polar molecules, such as glucose and amino acids, cross with the help of membrane proteins. They still move down their gradient, and no energy is spent. This is facilitated diffusion.
A channel protein forms a pore. Some channels open and close. Water crosses through channels called aquaporins. Large pores called porins are found in the outer membranes of plastids, mitochondria and some bacteria.
A carrier protein binds the molecule, changes shape and releases it on the other side.
Because there are only so many proteins, facilitated transport saturates. When every carrier is busy, a higher concentration outside cannot raise the rate. The proteins are also specific: each lets only certain substances through. And they can be blocked by inhibitors that bind to them.
A graph of the rate of uptake against the concentration of a solute outside the cell. Line A is straight and keeps rising through the origin: simple diffusion. Curve B rises steeply at first and then levels off at a maximum rate, marked Vmax: transport by a carrier protein. A dotted line marks half of Vmax, and the concentration where curve B reaches it is marked Km.
For a carrier, the rate follows
rate=Km+CVmaxC
Vmax is the largest rate. Km is the concentration that gives half of Vmax. A carrier with a small Km grabs its solute well even when there is little of it.
Notice where the two lines cross. At low concentration the carrier wins. At high concentration simple diffusion keeps rising, but the carrier has stopped.
Uniport, symport and antiport
A carrier can move one substance or two.
Uniport: one substance on its own.
Symport: two substances in the same direction at the same time.
Antiport: two substances in opposite directions.
Active transport
Root cells hold far more potassium than the soil water. To gather it, they must move it against its gradient. This needs energy, and it is called active transport.
Pumps use ATP directly. The proton pump of plant cells uses ATP to push hydrogen ions out of the cell.
The hydrogen ions then flow back in through a symport carrier, dragging another solute in with them, such as nitrate or sucrose. This is secondary active transport. The ATP was spent earlier, to build the gradient of hydrogen ions.
Like facilitated diffusion, active transport is specific and can saturate. Unlike it, it moves a substance uphill, and it stops when respiration stops.
Way
Protein?
Energy?
Simple diffusion
no
no
Facilitated diffusion
yes
no
Active transport
yes
yes, ATP
Try it in Python
The program names the way a substance crosses a membrane from three facts about it.
Practise with new numbers
Common mistakes
Saying facilitated diffusion uses energy. It uses proteins, but no energy. It goes down the gradient.
Thinking a carrier rate keeps rising. It saturates at Vmax.
Forgetting secondary active transport. A symport with hydrogen ions moves solutes uphill using energy stored in the gradient.
Using diffusion for long distances. Over a metre it takes years. Long trips need bulk flow.
Mixing up symport and antiport. Symport: same direction. Antiport: opposite directions.
Remember these
Simple diffusion: down the gradient, no protein, no energy.
Facilitated diffusion: down the gradient, through channels or carriers, specific, saturates.
Active transport: against the gradient, uses ATP directly or through an ion gradient.
Carrier: rate=Km+CVmaxC.
Check yourself
Try each one on your own first. If you are stuck, open a hint. Then check with Show the answer.
How does the time to diffuse change when the distance is three times as long?
Give two features shared by facilitated diffusion and active transport, and one that differs.
A carrier has Vmax=40nmol/(g min) and Km=2mmol/L. What is its rate at 2mmol/L?
Sucrose enters a cell together with hydrogen ions through the same protein. What kind of transport is this?
Why can a plant not rely on diffusion to move sugar from a leaf to a root 1m away?
References
OpenStax Biology 2e, chapter 5, Structure and Function of Plasma Membranes, sections 5.2 and 5.3.
Taiz, Zeiger, Møller and Murphy, Plant Physiology and Development, 6th edition, chapter 6, Solute Transport.
NCERT (2006). Biology, Textbook for Class XI, chapter 11, Transport in Plants.
Enroll free in Water Potential, Osmosis and Uptake by Roots
Every lesson is open to read. Enrolling also lets you:
Mark lessons done and carry on where you stopped.
Take the tests of this lesson and its course.
Count the course towards the certificate for its chapter.