The tallest trees are taller than a thirty-storey building, yet their top leaves never run dry. This lesson shows why root pressure and capillarity cannot explain this. Then it shows how the cohesion and tension theory does, with the gradient of water potential from soil to air and the evidence for it.
about 30 min1 simulation1 practice question
Lesson 2 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
A problem of height
The tallest living trees, coast redwoods, are more than 110m tall. Water must reach their top leaves every day. A tree has no heart and no pump. How does the water get there?
Water travels in the xylem. In flowering plants this is mostly vessels, long tubes of dead cells whose end walls have gone, and tracheids, narrower dead cells with tapering ends. Their walls are thickened with lignin, so they do not collapse. Water passes from one tube to the next through thin areas of the wall called pits. The upward movement of water and minerals in the xylem is called the ascent of sap.
Three ideas have been offered. Let us test each one.
Idea 1: root pressure
The last course showed that root pressure is real but small, at most a few tenths of a megapascal. It could hold up a column of 10 to 20 metres at most, and friction in the vessels cuts this further. Many trees show no root pressure at all, and on a sunny day the xylem is under tension, not pressure. So root pressure is not the main force.
Idea 2: capillarity
Water climbs up a narrow glass tube. This is capillarity, caused by the attraction of water to the wall and by surface tension. For a tube of radius r, the rise is
h=ρgr2γ
with γ=0.073N/m for water. In a vessel of radius 20μm:
First, ρgr=1000kg/m3×9.8m/s2×2×10−5m, which is 0.196N/m2. Then
h=0.196N/m22×0.073N/m
That is 0.745m. A tree is about a hundred times taller. Capillarity cannot do the job either.
Notice that even the narrowest vessel gives only a few metres. And narrow vessels carry water slowly.
Idea 3: cohesion and tension
The accepted explanation is the cohesion and tension theory, set out by Henry Dixon and John Joly in 1894. It is also called the transpiration pull theory.
Water evaporates from the moist walls of the mesophyll cells into the air spaces of the leaf, and leaves through the stomata.
As water leaves, the thin water film in the cell walls curves into tiny hollows. Surface tension in these films pulls on the water behind them. A tension (a negative pressure) is created.
The tension pulls water out of the nearest xylem vessels in the leaf.
Water molecules cling to one another by hydrogen bonds. This is cohesion. So the pull passes down the whole unbroken column, through the stem to the root.
Water molecules also cling to the walls of the vessels. This is adhesion. It helps the column hold on to the walls against gravity.
Water from the soil enters the root to replace what was pulled up.
The energy for all this comes from the Sun, which drives evaporation. The plant spends none of its own ATP on lifting water.
The water potential gradient
The whole path, from the soil to the air, runs downhill in water potential.
A tall tree drawn on the left, with labels down its side giving the water potential at five places on a summer day: air outside the leaf about minus 94 MPa, leaf cells minus 0.9 MPa, stem xylem minus 0.6 MPa, root xylem minus 0.3 MPa, soil water minus 0.1 MPa. An arrow up the trunk shows water moving from the soil towards the air, down the gradient of water potential.
The air is extremely dry in terms of water potential. For air at 50 per cent humidity and 20∘C, ψ=VˉwRTln(RH), with VˉwRT=135MPa. That gives 135MPa×ln0.5=−94MPa. Compared with this, the small steps inside the plant are tiny. So the leaf loses water to the air whenever the stomata are open.
How much tension is needed? Just holding a column of water h metres tall needs a pressure of ρgh. That is about 0.1MPa for each 10m. Friction in the vessels adds about as much again. So the top of a 100m tree needs a tension of about 2MPa. Water in narrow, clean tubes can resist far larger pulls before the column breaks.
The evidence
A tree trunk shrinks at midday. A fine gauge around the trunk shows the diameter falls when transpiration is fastest, as the stretched water columns pull the walls inward. It recovers at night.
A cut stem sucks in liquid. Cut a stem under a dye solution, and the dye is drawn up fast. The water was under tension.
Columns can break. When a column snaps, an air bubble forms. This is cavitation, and the vessel filled with air is said to have an embolism. Sensitive microphones pick up clicks as columns break in a drought.
Plants limit the damage. The pits between vessels stop air bubbles from spreading, so water flows around a blocked vessel. Root pressure can refill some vessels at night or in spring.
Try it in Python
The program compares the three ideas for a tree of a chosen height.
Practise with new numbers
Common mistakes
Saying the root pumps water to the top. The pull comes from the leaves, powered by evaporation.
Mixing up cohesion and adhesion. Cohesion is water to water. Adhesion is water to the wall.
Thinking the plant spends ATP to lift water. The energy comes from the Sun, through evaporation.
Saying the xylem water is under pressure on a sunny day. It is under tension, a negative pressure.
Forgetting cavitation. A broken column fills with air, and pits stop it from spreading.
Remember these
Root pressure and capillarity are too small to lift water up a tall tree.
Cohesion and tension (transpiration pull): evaporation makes a tension, cohesion carries it down the column, adhesion holds the column to the walls.
Water potential falls from the soil, through the plant, to the air.
Holding up a column: P=ρgh, about 0.1MPa for each 10m.
Check yourself
Try each one on your own first. If you are stuck, open a hint. Then check with Show the answer.
What is cohesion, and why is it needed for the transpiration pull?
How high would water rise by capillarity in a vessel of radius 40μm?
Where does the energy for the ascent of sap come from?
Why does the diameter of a tree trunk shrink at midday?
What is an embolism in a xylem vessel, and what limits its spread?
References
Taiz, Zeiger, Møller and Murphy, Plant Physiology and Development, 6th edition, chapter 4, Water Balance of Plants.
OpenStax Biology 2e, chapter 30, Plant Form and Physiology, section 30.5 Transport of Water and Solutes in Plants.
NCERT (2006). Biology, Textbook for Class XI, chapter 11, Transport in Plants.
Enroll free in Transpiration, the Ascent of Sap and Phloem Transport
Every lesson is open to read. Enrolling also lets you:
Mark lessons done and carry on where you stopped.
Take the tests of this lesson and its course.
Count the course towards the certificate for its chapter.