Try it on paper first. A hint, the key idea and the worked solution are here when you need them.
Two equal capacitors, each of , and two equal resistors, each of , make a ladder, as in the figure. An ideal battery of feeds the first resistor through a switch S. The first resistor leads to point A, and the first capacitor joins A to the bottom rail. The second resistor joins A to point B, and the second capacitor joins B to the bottom rail. Both capacitors are uncharged when S is closed at . Such a ladder is a first model of a long cable, or of a nerve fibre.
For (e), a student argues that the heat must depend on how the resistors are arranged, because the currents in them are so different. Check this argument against your answer.
Have you tried it?
Work it out on paper first. It is fine to get stuck or make a mistake: that is how we learn. When you are ready, go through the solution one step at a time, and check each step against your own.
Plan. Write the node equations, find the two decay rates, and build the current in the middle resistor from them. For the heat, use the battery's work and the stored energy.
Step 1. The start (a). Both capacitors are uncharged, so A is at and the whole battery voltage is across the first resistor: .
Step 2. Decay rates (b). At A: . At B: . Without the battery term, works when , so . With the time constants are and .
Step 3. The middle current (c). is zero at the start and at the end, so it is . Its derivative is zero when :
Step 4. Its size (d). At , B is uncharged and , so and . Then .
Step 5. Heat (e). At the end both capacitors are at , so a charge has passed through the battery. Its work is , and the capacitors store . The heat is the difference, .
Answer: (a) . (b) and . (c) . (d) . (e) .
Check. The heat is half the battery's work, exactly as for one capacitor charged through one resistor. The student is wrong: the split between the two resistors depends on the arrangement, but the total does not, and it does not even depend on .
Watch out. The time constants are not and . The two stages are linked, so the rates are the roots of a quadratic, and the slow one, , is longer than .
Log in to join the discussion.
Loading…