A statue whose bottom is a and top is b above your eye makes an angle θ at your eye with
Lesson 1 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
What you will be able to do
find the angle that a statue, a painting or a flag makes at your eye;
find the distance at which that angle is largest;
solve problems where two parts make equal angles at the eye.
Too close, too far
A statue stands on a tall pedestal in a square. Stand right at the foot and you see it at a steep slant, almost edge on. Walk far away and it looks tiny. In between, the statue fills the largest angle at your eye. Where is that place?
Measure every height from your eye level. Let the bottom of the statue be a above your eye and the top be b above it. You stand at the horizontal distance x.
A statue on a tall pedestal at the left, and an observer's eye at the right on a horizontal dashed line, the eye level. The bottom of the statue is a metres and the top b metres above eye level. Lines of sight from the eye go to the bottom and the top, and the angle theta between them is marked. A circle passes through the top and the bottom of the statue and just touches the eye level line at the eye.
The angle at the eye
The line to the top rises at β and the line to the bottom at α, with
tanβ=xb,
tanα=xa.
The statue makes the angle θ=β−α. The formula for the tangent of a difference gives
tanθ=1+tanβtanαtanβ−tanα.
Put in the two ratios and multiply the top and the bottom by x2:
tanθ=x2+ab(b−a)x.
The best distance
θ is largest when tanθ is largest, because tan grows on 0∘ to 90∘. Divide the top and the bottom by x:
tanθ=x+xabb−a.
So we want the bottom x+xab as small as possible. By the AM-GM inequality,
x+xab≥2ab,
with equality exactly when x=xab, that is x=ab. There
tanθmax=2abb−a.
If you know calculus, set the derivative of x+xab to zero: 1−x2ab=0 gives the same x=ab.
Example. The bottom is 4m and the top 9m above your eye. Then x=36=6m and tanθmax=125, so θmax≈22.62∘.
There is a neat picture behind this. Draw the circle through the top and the bottom of the statue that just touches your eye level. The touching point is the best place to stand. Every other point on the eye level line lies outside that circle, so it sees the statue at a smaller angle.
Equal angles
A flagstaff of length L stands on a tower of height H. From a point on the ground at the distance x, the tower and the flagstaff make equal angles θ at the eye. Here the eye is at ground level.
The tower gives tanθ=xH.
The tower and the flag together give tan2θ=xH+L.
The double-angle formula tan2θ=1−tan2θ2tanθ joins them:
xH+L=x2−H22Hx.
Solve for x: x2=L−HH2(H+L).
Example.H=10m and L=20m. Then x2=10100×30=300, so x=103m. Check: tanθ=31, so θ=30∘, and tan2θ=3=10330.
The formula needs L>H. A flag shorter than the tower can never make an equal angle, because the angle of the upper part is always squeezed.
Practise with new numbers
Try it in Python
The program works out the angle at the eye for many distances, finds the largest one by search, and compares it with ab.
Common mistakes
Heights from the ground. Measure a and b from your eye. Subtract your eye height first.
The ordinary mean. The best distance is ab, not 2a+b.
Mixing up θ and β.β is the elevation of the top. The statue's angle is β−α.
Forgetting the condition. Equal angles need the flag to be longer than the tower.
Remember these
tanθ=x2+ab(b−a)x, with heights above the eye.
Best distance x=ab, where tanθmax=2abb−a.
Equal angles: tanθ=xH and tan2θ=xH+L.
Check yourself
Try each one on your own first. If you are stuck, open a hint. Then check with Show the answer.
A sign is between 2m and 18m above your eye. Where should you stand to see it at the largest angle?
Why is the best distance never larger than the ordinary mean 2a+b?
What angle does a statue make at your eye when you stand right at the wall?
A tower 8m high has a flagstaff on it. At 83m from the foot, the tower makes 30∘ at the eye. If the flag makes an equal angle, how long is the flag?
If you stand twice as far as the best distance, is the angle half as big?
, the geometric mean of the two heights, by AM-GM or by calculus. When a flag and its tower make equal angles at your eye, the double-angle formula for
tan2θ
gives your distance.
about 25 min1 simulation1 practice question1 Python program5 questions to check yourself
This lesson is free to read. Enroll free to keep your place and take the tests.