A fact about the roots becomes an equation in the coefficients. Roots in arithmetic progression have their middle root at a third of the sum; roots in geometric progression have their middle root as the cube root of the product. Two equations share a root when a certain determinant condition holds, and a root is repeated when it is also a root of the derivative.
about 30 min1 simulation2 practice questions
Lesson 3 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
What you will be able to do
solve a cubic whose roots are in arithmetic, geometric or harmonic progression;
find the condition for two quadratics to share a root;
use the derivative to find a repeated root, and handle roots in a given ratio.
Three steps on a staircase
Three numbers in arithmetic progression are like three steps of a staircase: m−d, m and m+d. Their sum is 3m. So if the roots of a cubic are in arithmetic progression, the middle root is a third of the sum of the roots. One root comes for free.
Roots in arithmetic progression
Take x3+px2+qx+r=0. The sum of the roots is −p, so the middle root is m=−3p. It must satisfy the equation. Put it in and clear the fractions:
2p3−9pq+27r=0.
This is the condition for the roots to be in arithmetic progression.
Example. The roots of x3−12x2+39x−28=0 are in arithmetic progression. The middle root is 4. Check: 64−192+156−28=0. The other two add to 8 and multiply to 428=7. So they are 1 and 7, and the roots are 1, 4 and 7.
The graph of a cubic whose three roots are evenly spaced on the x-axis, at m minus d, m and m plus d. The middle root m is marked in a different colour, and the graph turns about the point where it crosses at m.
Roots in geometric progression
Write the roots as km, m and mk. Their product is m3=−r, so the middle root is the real cube root of −r. Putting it into the equation gives the condition
q3=p3r.
Roots in harmonic progression
The roots are in harmonic progression when their reciprocals are in arithmetic progression. Put x=y1 and multiply by y3. The roots of ry3+qy2+py+1=0 are the reciprocals. Now use the arithmetic test on this new cubic. You learn this change of variable in the next course.
A common root
When do a1x2+b1x+c1=0 and a2x2+b2x+c2=0 share a root t? Treat t2 and t as two unknowns and solve the pair by cross-multiplication. The square of the value found for t must equal the value found for t2. That gives the condition
(c1a2−c2a1)2
=(a1b2−a2b1)
×(b1c2−b2c1).
Often it is quicker to subtract the equations. The square terms cancel, and the common root drops out.
A repeated root
If α is a double root of f, then f(x)=(x−α)2g(x). Differentiate: f′(x) still has the factor x−α. So
f(α)=0 and f′(α)=0.
For example, x3−3x+k has f′(x)=3x2−3, so a repeated root is ±1. Then f(1)=0 gives k=2, and f(−1)=0 gives k=−2.
Roots in a given ratio
The roots of ax2+bx+c=0 are in the ratio m:n when they are mt and nt. Then (m+n)t=−ab and mnt2=ac. Remove t:
mnb2=(m+n)2ac.
Practise with new numbers
Try it in Python
The program builds cubics from roots in arithmetic and in geometric progression. It then tests the two conditions on each cubic.
Common mistakes
A non-monic cubic. For ax3+bx2+… the middle root of an arithmetic progression is −3ab.
The real cube root. In a geometric progression of real roots, the middle root is the real cube root of the product.
A common root that is not real. The condition also holds when the shared root is complex. Check what the question asks for.
A double root.f′(α)=0 alone is not enough. α must also be a root of f.
Remember these
Arithmetic progression: the middle root is −3p; test 2p3−9pq+27r=0.
Geometric progression: the middle root cubed is −r; test q3=p3r.
A repeated root: f(α)=f′(α)=0.
Ratio m:n in a quadratic: mnb2=(m+n)2ac.
Check yourself
Try each one on your own first. If you are stuck, open a hint. Then check with Show the answer.
The roots of x3−6x2+3x+10=0 are in arithmetic progression. Find them.
The roots of x3−7x2+14x−8=0 are in geometric progression. Find the middle root.
Find k if x2−5x+6=0 and x2−kx+8=0 share a root, and the shared root is the larger root of the first.
Find the repeated root of x3−5x2+8x−4=0.
The roots of x2+bx+8=0 are in the ratio 1:2. Find b.
References
H. S. Hall and S. R. Knight, Higher Algebra, the chapter on the theory of equations.
S. Barnard and J. M. Child, Higher Algebra, the chapter on the theory of equations.
Enroll free in Vieta's Formulas and Symmetric Functions
Every lesson is open to read. Enrolling also lets you:
Mark lessons done and carry on where you stopped.
Take the tests of this lesson and its course.
Count the course towards the certificate for its chapter.