Spectroscopy at work: isomers, reactions and mixtures
Spectroscopy is not only for naming unknowns. Chemists use it every day to tell isomers apart, to follow a reaction as it runs, and to measure what a mixture holds. This lesson shows how to pick the method that answers each question fastest.
about 20 min1 simulation1 practice question
Lesson 3 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
Choosing the right tool
Each method sees something different. Ask: what is different between the compounds I want to tell apart?
Difference
Best method
Molecular mass
Mass spectrum
Functional group
Infrared
Kinds of proton
Proton NMR
Symmetry of the skeleton
Carbon-13 NMR
Length of conjugation
UV-visible
Isomers have the same mass, so the molecular ion alone cannot tell them apart. Their fragments may.
Telling isomers apart
Take propanal, CH3CH2CHO, and propanone, CH3COCH3. Both are C3H6O with a C=O band.
Infrared: propanal shows the aldehyde C-H pair near 2720 and 2820cm−1. Propanone does not.
Proton NMR: propanal gives three signals, one at 9.8 ppm. Propanone gives a single line at 2.17 ppm.
Carbon-13 NMR: propanal gives three lines and propanone two.
Mass spectrum: propanone gives its base peak at 43, CH3CO+. Propanal gives strong peaks at 29 and 57.
Any one of these settles it. A good answer names the quickest and gives the reason.
Following a reaction
Oxidise propan-1-ol with acidified dichromate and distil the product as it forms. How do you know when the alcohol has gone, and whether the aldehyde has gone on to the acid?
Infrared: the broad O-H band near 3300cm−1 fades, and a C=O band near 1730cm−1 grows. If a very broad band from 2500 to 3000cm−1 appears, acid has formed.
Proton NMR: the CH2OH triplet near 3.6 ppm shrinks, and the CHO signal near 9.8 ppm grows. An acid would add a signal near 11 to 12 ppm.
Measuring a mixture
Integrals count protons. So the moles of each compound are in proportion to its integral divided by the number of protons in that signal.
Suppose a sample holds propanone and ethyl ethanoate. The propanone singlet (6H) has an integral of 30.0, and the ethyl ethanoate quartet (2H) has an integral of 8.0. Then the moles are in the ratio 30.0/6:8.0/2=5.0:4.0. Propanone is 5.0/9.0=55.6% of the moles.
Ultraviolet absorbance measures a mixture too. If two compounds absorb at two wavelengths, one Beer-Lambert equation at each wavelength gives two equations in two concentrations.
Practise with new numbers
Try it in Python
The program turns the integrals of a mixture into mole and mass percentages.
Common mistakes
Comparing raw integrals of signals with different numbers of protons. Divide first.
Using the molecular ion to tell isomers apart. It is the same for both.
Ignoring over-oxidation. Check for the acid as well as the aldehyde.
Picking a slow method when a quick one works. A single line in a proton spectrum can settle a question at once.
Remember these
Mass: mass and fragments. Infrared: groups. Proton NMR: kinds and numbers of proton. Carbon-13: symmetry. UV-visible: conjugation.
Moles in a mixture: integral divided by the protons in the signal.
A reaction is followed by the bands and signals that appear and disappear.
References
OpenStax Organic Chemistry (2023), Chapter 13 and Chapter 17, section 17.11 on the spectroscopy of alcohols.
Clayden, Greeves and Warren, Organic Chemistry, 2nd edition, Chapter 3.
Check yourself
Try each one on your own first. If you are stuck, open a hint. Then check with Show the answer.
Which single method tells propan-1-ol from propan-2-ol most quickly, and how?
During the oxidation of ethanol, a very broad infrared band from 2500 to 3000cm−1 appears. What has formed?
In a mixture, the signal of compound A (3H) has an integral of 6.0 and the signal of compound B (1H) has an integral of 2.0. What is the mole ratio of A to B?
Why can a mass spectrum tell pentan-2-one from pentan-3-one, though both have M at m/z 86?
Enroll free in UV-Visible Spectroscopy and Solving Structures from Combined Spectra
Every lesson is open to read. Enrolling also lets you:
Mark lessons done and carry on where you stopped.
Take the tests of this lesson and its course.
Count the course towards the certificate for its chapter.