Two kinds of smog hang over cities: a grey one on cold, damp days and a brown one on hot, sunny afternoons. This lesson explains how each forms, and why rain is slightly acidic even in clean air and much more acidic where coal and traffic pollute it.
about 25 min1 simulation1 practice question
Lesson 2 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
Two different smogs
The word smog joins smoke and fog. There are two kinds, and their chemistry is opposite.
Classical smog (also called London smog) forms in a cool, damp climate. Smoke, soot and sulphur dioxide from burning coal mix with fog. Sulphur dioxide is a reducing agent, so classical smog is a reducing smog. It irritates the lungs and has killed thousands of people in the past.
Photochemical smog forms on warm, dry, sunny days in cities with many cars. It needs sunlight, nitrogen oxides and hydrocarbons. Its main products, ozone and peroxides, are oxidising agents, so it is an oxidising smog. It is brown and hazy.
Classical
Photochemical
Weather
cool, damp
warm, sunny
Main cause
coal smoke, SO2
NOx, hydrocarbons
Nature
reducing
oxidising
How photochemical smog forms
Nitrogen dioxide absorbs sunlight and splits:
NO2→NO+O (with sunlight, hν)
The oxygen atom is very reactive. It joins an oxygen molecule:
O+O2→O3
Ozone reacts with nitrogen monoxide and gives back nitrogen dioxide:
O3+NO→NO2+O2
If nothing else happened, these three steps would balance, and only a little ozone would build up. Hydrocarbons change that. Their radicals turn NO back into NO2without using up ozone. So ozone piles up through the day. Hydrocarbons are also oxidised to methanal, HCHO, propenal (acrolein), CH2=CHCHO, and peroxyacetyl nitrate (PAN), CH3COOONO2.
A graph of the concentration of three gases in the air of a sunny city through one day, from 4 in the morning to 8 at night. Nitrogen monoxide, NO, rises to a sharp peak at about 8 in the morning, during the morning traffic. Nitrogen dioxide, NO2, peaks about two hours later. Ozone, O3, rises slowly through the morning and peaks in the early afternoon, at about 2 o'clock, then falls in the evening. The curves are a typical pattern, not one day's data.
The picture shows the pattern of a sunny day. NO rises with the morning traffic. NO2 peaks a little later, as NO is oxidised. Ozone peaks in the early afternoon, when the sunlight is strongest.
Effects. Ozone and PAN make the eyes water and the chest hurt. Ozone cracks rubber and damages leaves. Methanal and propenal irritate the eyes.
Control. A catalytic converter in the exhaust uses platinum, palladium and rhodium. It oxidises CO and hydrocarbons and reduces NO: 2CO+2NO→2CO2+N2. Fewer cars, cleaner fuels and trees that take up NO2 also help.
Acid rain
Pure water has a pH of 7. Rain is never pure. It dissolves carbon dioxide from the air:
CO2+H2O⇌H++HCO3−
How acidic does this make clean rain? Use Henry's law and the acid constant. The dissolved carbon dioxide is [CO2]=KHp, with KH=0.0340mol L−1atm−1. With Ka1=4.5×10−7 and almost all the H+ from this step, [H+]=Ka1KHp.
At p=420×10−6atm, [H+]=2.53×10−6mol/L, and the pH is about 5.6. So rain with a pH below 5.6 is called acid rain.
Where coal and traffic pollute the air, rain also holds sulphuric and nitric acids:
2SO2+O2+2H2O→2H2SO4
4NO2+O2+2H2O→4HNO3
These strong acids lower the pH to 4 or even below.
Set the strong acid to zero and move the carbon dioxide from 280 to 420 ppm. The pH falls only a little, from about 5.68 to 5.60. Now add 20 µmol/L of strong acid. The pH falls below 4.7. A small amount of strong acid matters far more than the carbon dioxide.
What acid rain does
Buildings and statues. Marble and limestone are calcium carbonate. CaCO3+H2SO4→CaSO4+H2O+CO2. The stone wears away and the surface flakes.
Lakes and soils. Acid lakes lose their fish. Acid leaches nutrients such as calcium and magnesium from soil, and frees aluminium ions that harm roots and gills.
Metals. Iron and steel corrode faster.
We fight acid rain by burning less coal, by removing sulphur from fuels, and by scrubbing the gas from chimneys with limestone: CaCO3+SO2→CaSO3+CO2, then 2CaSO3+O2→2CaSO4 (gypsum).
Try it in Python
The program works out the pH of rain from the carbon dioxide and any strong acid.
Common mistakes
Saying that any rain below pH 7 is acid rain. Clean rain is about 5.6 because of carbon dioxide.
Calling photochemical smog a reducing smog. It is oxidising: ozone and PAN.
Saying that cars give out ozone. Ozone forms in the air from NO2 and sunlight.
Counting one hydrogen ion for sulphuric acid. It gives two.
Expecting the ozone peak in the morning. It comes in the early afternoon, after the sunlight has worked for hours.