Why does barium sulphate stay at the bottom of a beaker while magnesium sulphate dissolves? Why does limestone need a furnace to break up, while magnesium carbonate breaks up in a Bunsen flame? This lesson explains both with two energies, the lattice enthalpy and the hydration enthalpy.
about 25 min1 simulation1 practice question
Lesson 3 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
Two energies decide whether a salt dissolves
When a salt dissolves, two things happen. The lattice must be broken apart into free ions. That needs the lattice enthalpy. Then the ions are surrounded by water molecules. That releases the hydration enthalpy.
ΔsolH=ΔlattH+ΔhydH
Here ΔlattH is the energy to separate the lattice (positive) and ΔhydH is the energy released by hydrating both ions (negative). If hydration releases more than the lattice costs, the salt usually dissolves well. Entropy also matters, but these two terms tell most of the story.
How do the two change down a group? Both get smaller in size as the cation grows. The question is which one falls faster.
The hydration enthalpy of the cation depends on the cation alone. It falls steeply as the cation grows.
The lattice enthalpy depends on the distance between the cation and the anion, r++r−. If the anion is large, a bigger cation changes that distance only a little. If the anion is small, a bigger cation changes it a lot.
Group 2 sulphates: less soluble down the group
The sulphate ion is large. So down group 2 the lattice enthalpy changes little, while the hydration enthalpy of the cation falls a lot. Dissolving becomes less favourable.
BeSO4 and MgSO4 dissolve well in water.
CaSO4 dissolves a little.
SrSO4 and BaSO4 hardly dissolve at all. Barium sulphate, with Ksp about 1.1×10−10, is so insoluble that it is swallowed safely before an X-ray of the stomach, even though barium ions are poisonous.
Group 2 hydroxides: more soluble down the group
The hydroxide ion is small. So down group 2 the lattice enthalpy falls quickly, faster than the hydration enthalpy. Dissolving becomes more favourable.
Be(OH)2 and Mg(OH)2 hardly dissolve. A suspension of magnesium hydroxide is used as an antacid.
Ca(OH)2 dissolves a little, less than 0.2g in 100mL of water. Its clear solution is lime water.
Ba(OH)2 dissolves to about 4g in 100mL. It is a strong alkali.
The basic strength of the hydroxides also rises down the group.
Group 1 salts
Almost all group 1 salts dissolve well. The exceptions are the lithium salts with small or highly charged anions: LiF, Li2CO3 and Li3PO4. Their lattice enthalpy is very high. The solubility of the carbonates and hydrogencarbonates of group 1 rises down the group, although sodium hydrogencarbonate dissolves less than sodium carbonate. That low solubility is the key to the Solvay process, which you will meet in the next course.
Thermal stability of carbonates
A carbonate breaks up on heating into the oxide and carbon dioxide: MCO3→MO+CO2. Why do the small cations make it happen more easily?
The carbonate ion is large, and its electron cloud is easy to distort. A small, highly charged cation, such as Mg2+, pulls that cloud towards itself. A C-O bond is weakened, and the ion splits into O2− and CO2 at a lower temperature. A large cation, such as Ba2+, polarises the carbonate less. So thermal stability rises down the group. The oxide formed also matters: a small cation sits well with the small O2− ion, which gives a high lattice enthalpy to the oxide and makes breaking up more favourable.
We can estimate the temperature where breaking up begins. The change becomes favourable when ΔG=ΔH−TΔS falls below zero, so at about T=ΔH/ΔS. For each carbonate, standard values at 298 K give:
MgCO3: ΔH=100.6kJ/mol, ΔS=175.0J/(K mol), so about 575K
CaCO3: 178.3kJ/mol and 160.6J/(K mol), so about 1110K
SrCO3: 234.6kJ/mol and 171.1J/(K mol), so about 1371K
BaCO3: 269.3kJ/mol and 172.1J/(K mol), so about 1565K
A bar chart of the estimated temperature at which each group 2 carbonate starts to break up into its oxide and carbon dioxide, worked out as the enthalpy change divided by the entropy change. Magnesium carbonate 575 K, calcium carbonate 1110 K, strontium carbonate 1371 K, barium carbonate 1565 K. A second row of labels gives the ionic radius of the metal ion: 72, 100, 118 and 135 pm.
These are estimates, because ΔH and ΔS change a little with temperature. The trend is clear. Beryllium carbonate is so unstable that it is kept only under carbon dioxide.
In group 1, only lithium carbonate breaks up at the temperature of a Bunsen flame. The larger alkali metal ions, with a charge of only 1, polarise the carbonate too little.
Choose calcium carbonate and set the temperature to 1000 K. ΔG is still positive. Raise it to 1200 K, and ΔG is negative.
Thermal stability of nitrates
The same idea works for nitrates. Small cations make them break up more easily, and to different products.
Group 2 nitrates, and lithium nitrate, give the oxide, nitrogen dioxide and oxygen: 2Mg(NO3)2→2MgO+4NO2+O2. Brown fumes are seen.
Sodium and potassium nitrates give only the nitrite and oxygen: 2KNO3→2KNO2+O2.
Practise with new numbers
Try it in Python
The program estimates the temperature where each group 2 carbonate starts to break up.
Common mistakes
Saying all group 2 salts get less soluble down the group. The sulphates do. The hydroxides do the opposite.
Explaining solubility with one energy alone. It is the balance of lattice and hydration enthalpy.
Thinking big cations break carbonates up more easily. Small cations polarise the carbonate more, so they break it up at lower temperatures.
Writing a nitrite as the product for magnesium nitrate. Group 2 nitrates give the oxide, nitrogen dioxide and oxygen.
Remember these
ΔsolH=ΔlattH+ΔhydH.
Down group 2: sulphates less soluble, hydroxides more soluble.
Carbonates and nitrates: more stable to heat down the group, because the larger cation polarises the anion less.
Estimate the breaking-up temperature with T=ΔH/ΔS.
References
OpenStax Chemistry 2e, Chapter 16, section 16.4, Free Energy, and Chapter 15, section 15.1, Precipitation and Dissolution.
Housecroft and Sharpe, Inorganic Chemistry, Chapter 12, The group 2 metals.
Check yourself
Try each one on your own first. If you are stuck, open a hint. Then check with Show the answer.
Why does the solubility of the group 2 hydroxides rise down the group?
Put CaCO3, MgCO3 and BaCO3 in order of the temperature at which they break up, lowest first.
Which salt gives brown fumes on heating: sodium nitrate or lithium nitrate?
Why can barium sulphate be swallowed for an X-ray, although barium ions are poisonous?
Enroll free in The Alkali and Alkaline Earth Metals: Trends, Anomalies and Stability
Every lesson is open to read. Enrolling also lets you:
Mark lessons done and carry on where you stopped.
Take the tests of this lesson and its course.
Count the course towards the certificate for its chapter.