Multistep routes: yield, order of steps and selectivity
A route of many good steps can still give a poor result. This lesson shows how yields multiply, why a convergent route beats a linear one, why the order of steps matters, and how a protecting group keeps one group safe while another reacts.
about 25 min1 simulation1 practice question
Lesson 1 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
Yields multiply
Suppose each step of a route gives 85 %. After one step you have 85 % of the moles you started with. After two steps you have 85 % of that. So the overall yield is the product of the step yields.
Y=y1×y2×y3⋯
With six steps at 85 %, Y=0.856=0.377, only 37.7 %. Every step you can remove from a route is worth a lot.
Linear and convergent routes
Two routes to the same product, each with eight steps drawn as arrows between dots. Top, a linear route: one line of eight arrows from the start to the product. Bottom, a convergent route: two branches of three arrows each, starting from two different compounds, meet at a coupling step, and one more arrow follows. A label says the longest line of the convergent route has five steps.
In a linear route each step follows the one before. In a convergent route two halves of the target are made separately and joined near the end. The losses of a branch are not passed through the other branch. So what matters is the longest line of steps from a starting compound to the product.
Set 85 % and 8 steps. The linear route keeps about a quarter of the product. Split into two branches, the same chemistry keeps nearly half. Large molecules such as medicines are almost always made by convergent routes.
Atom economy
Yield tells us how much of the possible product we got. Atom economy (AE) tells us how much of the mass of the reactants could ever end up in the product. Let Mp be the molar mass of the product we want, and ΣMr the sum of the molar masses of all the reactants.
AE=ΣMrMp×100%
An addition reaction puts every atom into the product, so its atom economy is 100 %. A substitution always throws something away. Ethanol made from ethene and steam has an atom economy of 100 %. Ethanol made from bromoethane and sodium hydroxide has about 30.9 %, because sodium bromide is made too. Green chemistry prefers routes with a high atom economy.
The order of the steps
A group already in a molecule changes what the next step does. Three examples show it.
Directing groups. To make 3-nitrobenzoic acid from methylbenzene, oxidise first (COOH directs to the 3-position), then nitrate. To make 4-nitrobenzoic acid, nitrate first (methyl directs to the 2- and 4-positions), then oxidise.
A group that blocks a reagent. Friedel-Crafts reactions fail on a ring with a nitro group. So any alkyl or acyl group goes on before the nitro group.
A group that the next reagent would destroy. An aldehyde does not survive a Grignard reagent made in the same molecule. So such steps are planned with care, or the aldehyde is protected.
Selectivity
A good step changes only the part of the molecule we want.
Chemoselectivity: one functional group reacts and another does not. Sodium borohydride reduces a ketone but leaves an ester.
Regioselectivity: one position reacts rather than another. HBr adds by Markovnikov's rule; a methyl group directs to the 2- and 4-positions.
Stereoselectivity: one arrangement in space forms rather than another. The next course deals with it.
Protecting groups
Sometimes no reagent is selective enough. Then we hide one group for a while. A protecting group is put on, does its job, and is taken off.
The classic case is aniline. Nitric acid oxidises aniline, and in strong acid the anilinium ion, C6H5NH3+, directs to the 3-position. Bromine water gives 2,4,6-tribromoaniline at once, because -NH2 makes the ring so reactive. The cure is to turn the amino group into an amide first.
Protect. Aniline with ethanoic anhydride (or ethanoyl chloride with pyridine) gives N-phenylethanamide, also called acetanilide.
React. The amide group is still 2- and 4-directing, but milder. Nitration gives mainly the 4-nitro product. Bromine in ethanoic acid gives mainly the 4-bromo product.
Deprotect. Heat with aqueous acid or alkali. The amide is hydrolysed and the amine comes back.
Making 4-nitroaniline with a protecting group, in four boxes from left to right. Aniline, with ethanoic anhydride, gives N-phenylethanamide (acetanilide). With concentrated nitric and sulphuric acids, this gives N-(4-nitrophenyl)ethanamide. Hydrolysis with aqueous acid and heat gives 4-nitroaniline. A crossed-out arrow below shows that aniline with nitric acid directly gives oxidised tar and some 3-nitroaniline.
At olympiad level other protecting groups appear. A ketone or aldehyde is hidden as an acetal with ethane-1,2-diol and an acid catalyst. The acetal is stable to bases, Grignard reagents and hydrides. Dilute aqueous acid removes it afterwards.
Practise with new numbers
Try it in Python
The program prints the overall yield of a linear route of one to eight steps, and of a convergent route.
Common mistakes
Adding yields instead of multiplying them. Three steps at 90 % give 72.9 %, not 70 %.
Counting all the steps of a convergent route. Count the longest line from a starting compound.
Confusing yield and atom economy. A step can give 100 % yield and still throw away most of the mass.
Forgetting to remove a protecting group. The last step must give back the group you hid.
References
Clayden, Greeves and Warren, Organic Chemistry, 2nd edition (2012), Chapter 23 (chemoselectivity and protecting groups) and Chapter 28.
NCERT Chemistry Part II for Class 12, Unit 13 (protection of the amino group by acetylation).
Check yourself
Try each one on your own first. If you are stuck, open a hint. Then check with Show the answer.
A route has three steps with yields of 90 %, 80 % and 50 %. What is the overall yield?
Why is aniline acetylated before it is brominated, when 4-bromoaniline is wanted?
What is the atom economy of making ethanol by hydration of ethene?
Name the kind of selectivity in each case: (a) HBr adds to propene to give mainly 2-bromopropane; (b) NaBH4 reduces the ketone of a keto ester.
Enroll free in Planning a Synthesis: Multistep Routes, Retrosynthesis and Reaction Schemes
Every lesson is open to read. Enrolling also lets you:
Mark lessons done and carry on where you stopped.
Take the tests of this lesson and its course.
Count the course towards the certificate for its chapter.