The greenhouse effect and global warming potentials
A car parked in the sun gets hotter inside than the air outside. The Earth is warmed in a similar way by a few gases in its air. This lesson shows why those gases trap heat, how warm the Earth would be without them, and how to compare one gas with another.
about 25 min1 simulation1 practice question
Lesson 1 of 3Show all lessonsHide
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
A blanket of gases
Sit in a car parked in the sun with the windows closed. It gets very hot. Light comes in through the glass, warms the seats, and the warm seats give out infrared radiation that cannot get out so easily. The Earth's air does something similar. A few gases let sunlight through but absorb the infrared that the warm ground gives out. This is the greenhouse effect.
The effect is natural and good. Without it the Earth would be frozen. The problem is that we are making it stronger. That extra warming is global warming.
A diagram of the energy balance of the Earth. Sunlight of 340 watts per square metre, averaged over the globe, comes in from the top. About 100 of it is reflected by clouds, ice and the ground, and about 240 is absorbed. The warm ground gives out infrared radiation. Greenhouse gases in the air absorb much of this infrared and send part of it back down, so the ground is at about 288 K. Without them the ground would be at about 255 K.
How warm would the Earth be without it?
The Sun gives S=1361W/m2 at the Earth's distance (the solar constant). The Earth catches this on a disc of area πR2 but gives out heat from a whole sphere of area 4πR2. A fraction α=0.30, the albedo, is reflected straight back. In balance, the heat given out equals the sunlight absorbed:
σT4=4S(1−α)
Here σ=5.670×10−8W m−2K−4 is the Stefan-Boltzmann constant. The right side is 238W/m2. We want T, so T=(5.670×10−8238)1/4=255K.
That is −18∘C. The real average surface is about 288K (15∘C). The difference of 33 K is the natural greenhouse effect.
Which gases trap heat?
A gas absorbs infrared light only if its molecule changes its dipole moment as it vibrates.
Nitrogen and oxygen, N2 and O2, have two identical atoms. Their stretch changes no dipole. They do not absorb infrared, though they are 99 % of the air.
Carbon dioxide has no dipole at rest, but its bending and its uneven stretch do make one. So CO2 absorbs infrared strongly.
Water vapour, methane, CH4, nitrous oxide, N2O, ozone and the CFCs and HFCs absorb too.
Water vapour is the largest greenhouse gas. Its amount follows the temperature: warmer air holds more water. So it acts as a feedback that strengthens any warming started by the other gases.
Sources of the greenhouse gases we add
Carbon dioxide: burning coal, oil and gas; making cement; cutting forests. It rose from about 280 ppm before 1800 to about 420 ppm today.
Methane: rice fields, cattle, landfill sites, leaks from gas wells and pipes.
Nitrous oxide: nitrogen fertilisers in soil, and some industry.
Fluorinated gases: HFCs in refrigerators and air conditioners, and SF6 in electrical switchgear.
Radiative forcing
The extra energy held in by a change in a gas is the radiative forcing, ΔF, in W/m2. For carbon dioxide a good fit is
ΔF=5.35lnC0C
with C0=280 ppm. The warming at equilibrium is roughly ΔT=λΔF, where the climate sensitivityλ is about 0.8K m2W−1. The logarithm means that each doubling adds the same forcing, 5.35ln2=3.7W/m2.
Set 560 ppm, double the value before 1800. The forcing is 3.71 W/m2 and the warming about 3.0 K. Now set 1120 ppm. The warming is about 5.9 K: the second doubling adds the same 3.0 K, not more.
Global warming potential
How do we compare a kilogram of methane with a kilogram of carbon dioxide? We use the global warming potential (GWP). It is the warming caused by 1 kg of a gas over a time, usually 100 years, divided by the warming from 1 kg of carbon dioxide over the same time. So carbon dioxide has a GWP of 1.
Gas
GWP (100 years)
Life in air
CO2
1
centuries
CH4
28
about 12 years
N2O
265
about 120 years
HFC-134a
1300
about 14 years
SF6
23500
thousands of years
These values are from the Fifth Assessment Report (AR5) of the IPCC. The Sixth Report (AR6) gives slightly different ones, such as 27 to 30 for methane and 273 for nitrous oxide. Always use the values a question gives.
The carbon dioxide equivalent of an emission is its mass times its GWP:
mCO2-e=m×GWP
What warming does
Sea level rises, because warm water takes up more space and land ice melts. Glaciers shrink, heat waves come more often, and rain patterns change. Warm seas take up more carbon dioxide, which makes them more acidic and harms corals and shellfish.
Control. Use less fossil fuel and more solar, wind and water power. Use energy more efficiently. Protect and plant forests. Capture methane from landfills and burn it for energy. Capture carbon dioxide from large chimneys and store it underground.
Try it in Python
The program adds up the carbon dioxide equivalent of what a small farm gives out in a year.
Common mistakes
Mixing up the greenhouse effect and the ozone hole. One traps infrared. The other lets in ultraviolet.
Thinking nitrogen and oxygen are greenhouse gases. They do not change their dipole when they vibrate.
Using the mass of carbon dioxide from burning instead of the GWP. The GWP compares warming, not chemistry.
Assuming warming grows in proportion to the carbon dioxide. It grows with the logarithm.
Forgetting the factor 4. Sunlight falls on a disc, but heat leaves a sphere.
Remember these
Without greenhouse gases, σT4=S(1−α)/4 gives 255 K. The real surface is about 288 K.
A gas traps infrared if its vibration changes its dipole moment.