Course 36.3Lesson 1 of 3
A crab on the shore can choose small, middle-sized or large mussels. Which should it eat, and when should a bird leave a bush with few berries left? This lesson builds simple models of feeding and tests them against what animals really do.
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
Watch a shore crab among mussels. Small mussels open fast but hold little flesh. Large ones hold a lot, but they take a long time to crack and can break a claw. Which should the crab choose?
Optimal foraging theory gives a way to answer. It says that natural selection favours ways of feeding that give the most net energy per unit time. An animal that feeds faster has more time and energy left for escaping, finding mates and raising young. The theory makes clear predictions that we can test.
The profitability of a food item is the energy it gives, , divided by the time needed to catch, open and eat it, the handling time :
| Mussel | Energy (J) | Handling (s) |
|---|---|---|
| small | 150 | 30 |
| medium | 900 | 75 |
| large | 2000 | 250 |
The small mussel gives . The medium one gives . The large one gives . So the model predicts that the crab should prefer middle-sized mussels. Studies of shore crabs found just that pattern.
Northwestern crows on the Pacific coast of Canada break whelks by dropping them on rocks. They pick large whelks and drop them from about . A lower drop needs many more tries. A higher one costs more climbing for little gain. About gives the least total climbing for each whelk broken.
A bird finds two kinds of prey. Should it take both? The model ranks prey by profitability.
So when the best prey is common, the bird should ignore poor prey, however common the poor prey is. When the best prey becomes scarce, the bird should start to eat both. Great tits that took mealworm pieces from a moving belt in a classic test behaved close to this prediction.
Food often comes in patches: a bush of berries, a field with worms. As an animal feeds, the patch runs down, and each minute gives less. Travel to the next patch takes time and gives nothing.
Eric Charnov answered the question in 1976 with the marginal value theorem. The animal should leave when its rate of gain in the patch falls to the best average rate it can get over the whole trip, travel and feeding together. With a travel time and a time in the patch , the rate over a trip is
The picture shows the result. When the travel time is long, the best stay is longer. A starling that flies far from its nest to collect insects for its chicks brings back a larger load than one that feeds close to the nest.
Slide the time in the patch until the rate is highest. Then make the travel time longer. Notice that the best stay grows.
An animal that feeds where it is easily seen may be eaten. Small sunfish feed in open water, where food is rich, when no predator is near. When predatory bass are in the pond, the small fish move into weed beds with less food but more cover. Large sunfish, too big for the bass, stay in the open. So the best choice balances energy against risk.
The program finds the best stay in a patch for three travel times.
Try each one on your own first. If you are stuck, open a hint. Then check with Show the answer.
Every lesson is open to read. Enrolling also lets you:
Log in to join the discussion.
Loading…
This lesson is free to read. Enroll free to keep your place and take the tests.