Course 36.2Lesson 2 of 3
A flock of starlings swirls in the evening sky, and worker bees die defending a hive that is not theirs to breed in. This lesson weighs the costs and benefits of living in groups, explains dominance and territory, and shows how kin selection and reciprocal help can explain altruism.
Try the code and the simulations beside the lesson.
A pigeon feeding alone must keep looking up for hawks. In a flock it can feed more and look up less. Groups bring benefits, but also costs.
Benefits.
Costs.
So a group is favoured only when its benefits outweigh its costs. Many birds feed in flocks in winter but hold territories in spring.
How likely is it that at least one bird is alert? If each bird looks up at a given moment with chance , the chance that none of birds is looking up is . So the chance that at least one bird is alert is
Notice how the curve flattens. Each extra bird helps less, while competition for food keeps growing.
Thorleif Schjelderup-Ebbe watched hens in 1922. Hen A pecked hen B, B pecked C, and so on. Each hen knew its place. This pecking order is a dominance hierarchy. Fights are rare once it is set up, because each animal gives way to those above it. Dominant animals get first choice of food and mates.
A territory is an area that an animal defends against others of its species. It is worth defending only when its gain (food, a nest site, mates) is larger than the cost in time, energy and risk.
A worker honeybee stings an intruder and dies. A female ground squirrel calls when a hawk appears, and the call makes her easier to catch. Altruism is behaviour that helps another animal at a cost to the helper. How can natural selection keep it?
Kin selection. Relatives share genes. A gene that makes an animal help its relatives can spread through the offspring of those relatives. The relatedness is the chance that two animals share a gene through common descent. Parent and offspring have . Full siblings have , half siblings , first cousins .
W. D. Hamilton put this as a rule in 1964. Helping is favoured when
where is the extra offspring the relative raises and is the offspring the helper gives up.
Belding's ground squirrels fit the rule. Females stay near where they were born, so their neighbours are often kin. Males move away. Females give alarm calls far more often than males.
Haplodiploidy. In bees, ants and wasps, females come from fertilised eggs and have two sets of chromosomes. Males come from unfertilised eggs and have one set.
Sisters with the same father share all of his genes and half of their mother's, on average. So two full sisters have . A worker is more closely related to her sisters than she would be to her own daughters (). This may help to explain why workers raise sisters instead of breeding. It is not the whole story: termites are not haplodiploid, yet they are just as social.
Colonies like these, with a breeding queen, sterile workers that care for the young, and generations that overlap, are called eusocial. The naked mole-rat is a eusocial mammal.
Reciprocal altruism. Vampire bats feed on blood at night. A bat that fails to feed for two or three nights in a row can starve. A bat that has fed well often brings up blood for a hungry roost-mate, sometimes one that is not related. Bats tend to feed those that fed them before. Help like this works only when animals meet again and again and can recognise one another, so that cheats can be refused.
The program tests Hamilton's rule for four kinds of relative.
Try each one on your own first. If you are stuck, open a hint. Then check with Show the answer.
Every lesson is open to read. Enrolling also lets you:
Log in to join the discussion.
Loading…
This lesson is free to read. Enroll free to keep your place and take the tests.