Why the mean can mislead you
Seven friends have about 25 marbles each. One friend arrives with 500, and the average jumps to 84. Who is right: the mean or the median? A short story with numbers you can change.
17 November 2026 · 2 min read · All posts by StemPy Lab

Seven friends compare how many marbles they own: and .
Add them up: . Divide by : the mean is . That is a good picture of the group.
Then an eighth friend walks in. This friend has marbles.
Add again: . Divide by : the mean is now . Notice how far that is from .
Does that describe anybody? Seven of the eight friends have about . Nobody has . The new average is true, but it tells a false story.
Run it
The mean is . The median is (the program shows it as 25.0).
The median is the middle value of the sorted list. It does not care how far away the biggest value is, so the friend with 500 marbles hardly changes it.
Which one should I use?
| Question | Use | Why |
|---|---|---|
| How much is the fair share of a prize pool? | Mean | You want the same amount for each. |
| What does a typical person earn? | Median | A few huge salaries do not drag it. |
| Which shoe size should a shop order most? | Mode | It is the most common. |
The value that is far from the others has a name: an outlier. When you see one, ask two questions. Is it a mistake, such as an extra zero? Or is it real, and the data really is uneven?
Try it yourself
The lesson
A single number can hide a lot. A good report names the average that it uses, says why, and mentions any outlier. You can practise this in the free book Statistics First Steps. Chapter 3, Averages, is about exactly this. The book starts from "what is data?" and ends with a small weather project. After it, Statistics Essentials goes on to distributions, standard deviation and z-scores.
Discussion (0)
Log in to join the discussion.
Loading…

AP Statistics: units, two practice exams and Section I pacing
What AP Statistics Section I looks like, the five units, a common slip for each unit, a minute-by-minute pace for 40 questions, and a two-week and a four-week plan with two free practice exams.
ApAp statisticsPractice exam

