The rate constants for nitration of benzene and of hexadeuteriobenzene (C6D6) by mixed acid at 298K give kH/kD=1.0. For sulphonation of the same pair by fuming sulfuric acid at 298K, kH/kD=1.7. Both reactions pass through an arenium ion (sigma complex). In it the attacked carbon is sp3 and still carries its H or D. A primary isotope effect clearly above 1 appears only when a C–H (or C–D) bond is broken in, or before, the rate-limiting stage. Which inference about the two mechanisms is correct?