Try it on paper first. A hint, the key idea and the worked solution are here when you need them.
Vampire bats roost in groups of the same females for many years. A bat that finds no blood for two or three nights in a row can starve. A bat that has fed well sometimes brings up blood for a hungry roost-mate.
A study notes who feeds whom. It finds that a bat is much more likely to feed a roost-mate that fed it in the past. Some pairs that share blood are close kin; some are not related at all.
Groups help animals to spot predators, dilute the risk to each one and find food, but they bring competition and disease. A dominance hierarchy settles who gets food or mates without constant fights. Altruism helps another at a cost to the helper. Kin selection favours it when Hamilton's rule holds:
where is relatedness, the benefit to the relative and the cost to the helper, both in offspring. In haplodiploid bees, ants and wasps, full sisters have . Reciprocal altruism helps a non-relative who is likely to return the help. With birds each alert with chance , the chance that at least one is alert is
Check an answer or open a hint to unlock the worked solution.
Have you tried it?
Work it out on paper first. It is fine to get stuck or make a mistake: that is how we learn. When you are ready, go through the solution one step at a time, and check each step against your own.
Step 1. (a) Kin selection needs . For an unrelated bat is close to 0, so is close to 0, which cannot be larger than the cost.
Step 2. (b) Reciprocal altruism: help now, repaid later. It needs the same animals to meet again and again, and the bats roost together for years. It also needs them to recognise each other and remember who helped, so help can go to those who return it.
Step 3. (c) A starving bat is close to death, so a small meal can give it many extra hours to find food. A full bat loses only a little of its reserve and is far from starving. So the benefit to the receiver is larger than the cost to the giver, which is what makes the exchange pay for both over time.
Step 4. (d) Roost-mates would stop feeding it, since bats feed those that fed them. The cheat would then face starvation alone on bad nights. Because cheats are refused, the cheating strategy does not spread, and sharing stays stable.
Answer: (a) is near 0 for non-kin; (b) reciprocal altruism: repeated meetings, recognition and memory; (c) the receiver gains far more than the giver loses; (d) the cheat is refused help, so sharing stays stable.
Log in to join the discussion.
Loading…