Try it on paper first. A hint, the key idea and the worked solution are here when you need them.
A research group grows a crop in hydroponic tanks. In each tank the full nutrient solution is changed in one way only. Decide for each element whether the result shows that it is essential, and give the test of essentiality that decides it.
An element is essential when a plant cannot complete its life cycle without it, when no other element can do its job, and when it takes part directly in the plant's metabolism. Hydroponics, growing plants in a nutrient solution without soil, tests this: leave out one element and see whether the plant fails. Seventeen elements are essential. Macronutrients (C, H, O, N, P, K, S, Ca, Mg) are present at more than in each kilogram of dry matter. Micronutrients (Fe, Mn, Cu, Mo, Zn, B, Cl, Ni) are present at less.
where is in mmol per kg, in mg per kg and is the molar mass in g/mol.
Check an answer or open a hint to unlock the worked solution.
Have you tried it?
Work it out on paper first. It is fine to get stuck or make a mistake: that is how we learn. When you are ready, go through the solution one step at a time, and check each step against your own.
Plan. Test each result against the three tests of Arnon and Stout: the life cycle, a specific need, and a direct role in metabolism.
Step 1. (a) The plants complete the life cycle without W. So W fails the first test. It is at most a beneficial element.
Step 2. (b) Without X no viable seed forms, so the life cycle is not completed. Y cannot replace it, so the need is specific. X passes the first two tests, and it is very likely essential. A study of where X acts in metabolism would complete the proof.
Step 3. (c) Q can replace P, so the need for P is not specific. P fails the second test. From this result alone P is not shown to be essential.
Step 4. (d) R acts only by holding back a poison. It does not work directly in metabolism, and it is not needed once S is gone. R fails the third test. It is not essential.
Answer: (a) not essential, fails the life-cycle test; (b) essential, passes the life-cycle and specific-need tests; (c) not shown to be essential, fails the specific-need test; (d) not essential, fails the direct-role test.
Watch out. A larger plant (part a) is not the same as a plant that cannot finish its life cycle.
Log in to join the discussion.
Loading…