Try it on paper first. A hint, the key idea and the worked solution are here when you need them.
A planet is a uniform sphere of radius and centre O. Before anything was dug out, the gravitational field at its surface was . A spherical cavity of radius is then hollowed out, with its centre C at a distance from O, so that the cavity touches the surface at a point S and reaches the centre O, as shown in the figure. Ignore the planet's rotation.
Have you tried it?
Work it out on paper first. It is fine to get stuck or make a mistake: that is how we learn. When you are ready, go through the solution one step at a time, and check each step against your own.
Step 1. Superposition. The planet with the cavity is the full planet (density ) plus a sphere of density filling the cavity. Inside a uniform sphere, the field at a point with position from its centre is . For a point P in the cavity:
This is the same vector at every point of the cavity: the field there is uniform, pointing from C towards O. Before the digging the surface field was , and , so the field in the cavity is .
Step 2. The fall through the cavity. S, C and O lie on one line, along the field. So the stone falls straight from S to O, a distance , with a constant acceleration of :
Step 3. The full planet. Inside it the field is , towards the centre, so the stone moves in simple harmonic motion with . From rest at the surface to the centre is a quarter of a period: . The speed at the centre is .
The two speeds are equal. On the way down, the work done per kilogram is the area under the graph of field against distance: a triangle of height and base for the full planet, and a rectangle of height and the same base for the cavity. Both areas are . The stone in the full planet arrives sooner because it feels a strong pull at the start.
Step 4. The point S'. The full planet pulls with towards O. The removed sphere had of the mass, centred at C, a distance from S'. It would have pulled with , also towards O. Without it: , towards O.
Answer: (a) everywhere in the cavity, from C towards O. (b) ; . (c) ; . (d) towards O.
Check. At O itself the full planet gives no field, because O is its centre. So the whole field at O comes from the negative sphere, whose centre C is away: , pushing away from C, that is from C towards O. This matches Step 1.
Watch out. Inside the cavity the field does not change with the distance from O, so the stone does not move in simple harmonic motion here, as it would in a tunnel through a full planet.
Log in to join the discussion.
Loading…