Try it on paper first. A hint, the key idea and the worked solution are here when you need them.
A light ball is thrown from ground level on a flat beach. A steady wind blows along the beach. Take its effect to be a steady horizontal acceleration of the ball, in the direction of the wind, on top of the usual downwards, and ignore any other effect of the air. The ball is always thrown at , in the vertical plane that contains the direction of the wind, as shown in the figure.
Have you tried it?
Work it out on paper first. It is fine to get stuck or make a mistake: that is how we learn. When you are ready, go through the solution one step at a time, and check each step against your own.
Plan. The ball moves with a constant acceleration, so it behaves as if gravity were tilted. Use that for (a). For (b) and (c), write the range as a function of the angle and find its largest value.
Step 1. Effective gravity. The acceleration has downwind and downwards. Its size is , and it points below the horizontal, downwind, at an angle whose tangent is , that is .
Step 2. Back to the hand (a). Throw the ball exactly against the effective gravity: upwind, at above the horizontal. Its velocity and acceleration then lie along one line, so it moves along a straight line, slows down, stops and comes back along the same line to the hand. It is like a vertical throw with :
The greatest height is .
Step 3. The range on level ground. Thrown at , the ball is in the air for , because the wind does not change its upward motion. Downwind (plus) or upwind (minus):
Here and . The largest value of is .
Step 4. Downwind (b). The largest value is reached when , so and . Then .
Step 5. Upwind (c). Now , so and . Then .
Answer: (a) above the horizontal, upwind; ; ; a straight line. (b) ; . (c) ; .
Check. With no wind, both angles would be and both ranges . The wind tilts the best angles by the same amount either way, steeper downwind (more time for the wind to help) and flatter upwind (less time for it to hurt).
Watch out. The time of flight on level ground depends only on and the upward part of the velocity, not on the wind. But the angle for the greatest range is no longer .
Log in to join the discussion.
Loading…